You have a limited pool of data, the same as most of us. Almost all the medical experts are telling us contact sports are not a good idea right now, but because younger people are more likely to survive the virus, and we desperately want football, we condemn them.
I am not trying to be condescending, but your very assertion that experts are using bad science is condescending in itself.
Either way, the reality is that most likely we will not see college football in 2020. If for no other reason than there is no way to justify any potential risk to student athletes and the loved ones they come into contact with while continuing to deny them compensation at market value for their services. As has been mentioned, it's a legal nightmare waiting to happen. All the P5 conferences are ready to cancel, but no one either wants to be the first or last to do so for PR reasons.