The problem with your Argument is that Paul Johnson has won an ACC title..been to 2 OB and a Peach and has two 10 win seasons...
And? The last 6 years Johnson (42-37) has a worse record than Gaily (44-32) had in his 6 years here. And if it wasn't for Laskey's injury forcing Johnson to play the better back, it would be even worse.
I guess you didn't enjoy the '14 OB season?Come on guys. The problem is Paul Johnson and the TO. He is not going to change, he doesn't know anything else. Recruiting is the major problem and most highschool players are not going to sign on because they do not like his offense. He is going down with the ship trying to prove his system will work. So keep banging your head thinking things are going to get better. For the most part Tech will always be a 7/5 team.
I guess you didn't enjoy the '14 OB season?
And? The last 6 years Johnson (42-37) has a worse record than Gaily (44-32) had in his 6 years here. And if it wasn't for Laskey's injury forcing Johnson to play the better back, it would be even worse.
So you are saying you would rather have Chan Gailey who never went to a Peach Bowl or to 2 Orange Bowls (winning 1), or won the ACC Title... You were happy with the 7 win seasons and the Emerald Bowls and losing to Wake Forest in the ACC Title game....And? The last 6 years Johnson (42-37) has a worse record than Gaily (44-32) had in his 6 years here. And if it wasn't for Laskey's injury forcing Johnson to play the better back, it would be even worse.
One flaw in your argument is that after Iowa (undeniably the best defense we have faced), the offense still managed to maintain and improve, leading up to 2014. What made Iowa's defense so formidable was their discipline. What made Clemson's defense so formidable was their size and speed. I don't think we have ever, and perhaps never will, face a defense as disciplined as Iowa's was, but we will continue to face big and fast defenses like Clemson's. Do we have an answer? I would think after 35 years of coaching this offensive scheme, Johnson would have an answer, but we haven't seen it yet. Let's hope we do and SOON.As I have said in prior posts, if you are not innovating you are getting left behind. This offense has now been seen and studied within the ACC for 9 years. They have seen the things that work against it and the defensive coordinators are not all stupid. This offense works well when it is executed but teams seem to have found ways to disrupt or execution. The first time it was really obvious to me was when we played Iowa in a bowl game several years ago. They absolutely demolished us. Not sure what the answer is but continuing to do the same thing over and over again and expecting different results is called insanity. There is no doubt that this offense makes recruiting more difficult for elite lineman and QB's. We get the HS QB's that are more run oriented and not great passers but want to still play QB in college. The linemen want to play in an offense that is more pass protection oriented like the pro game. WR's want to get more than 1 or 2 passes thrown to them a game. We get kids that want an education and are good (but not elite) players. I am very proud of the character and classroom achievement of our players.
So you are saying you would rather have Chan Gailey who never went to a Peach Bowl or to 2 Orange Bowls (winning 1), or won the ACC Title... You were happy with the 7 win seasons and the Emerald Bowls and losing to Wake Forest in the ACC Title game....
You are making NO SENSE!!
I am not picking on the kid because he is a well respected player and athlete, but just look at JJ Green, for example, and watch the game tape. He is a good runner, but he hasn't learned to block in space yet and he really doesn't have a feel for what we are doing. I'll bet if you lined him up and gave him deep handoffs in a zone block scheme, he would be more than fine.
So you're saying the players aren't being prepped or coached properly? Isn't that what off season workouts are for or spring practice is for? When players are having a hard time year after year doing what the "system" requires to work, it maybe the system. It is not like Tech is recruiting a bunch of dumb jocks that can't read or get out of the rain when it is raining. JJ Green isn't the only A back out there and saying he isn't ready is an indictment on the rest of A backs that aren't playing. Hell JT looks lost sometimes and how long has he been studying and working in the Wing T? That says more than anything else.The offense is not the problem. This is the same offense that rewrote the offensive efficiency record books a mere 16 games ago. Do you remember the orange bowl and the "they just can't stop it folks"? What has changed are the players running the offense. Are defenses evolving? Of course. Is our offense evolving? I would say so, based on the plays I am seeing run.
The sad truth, IMHO, is that the kids on the current roster have not learned to run the offense yet. I am not picking on the kid because he is a well respected player and athlete, but just look at JJ Green, for example, and watch the game tape. He is a good runner, but he hasn't learned to block in space yet and he really doesn't have a feel for what we are doing. I'll bet if you lined him up and gave him deep handoffs in a zone block scheme, he would be more than fine. That is the stuff I am talking about. When was the last play you saw one of our WRs hit a huge play? Do you guys realize we are never behind the defense anymore? It used to be commonplace, with guys running free deep all the time. Our level of team execution and stretching ability at the boundary are down right now. I'm not sure what we can do for the latter but the former can and should be improved upon.
I can't help u with the understanding problem. Obviously we are watching two different performances. Maybe it's not fair to compare him to other QBs, but I would rather have Josh any day of the week. Saying that is not saying much for this offense since it is year 9 of Paul running the ship.JT does not look lost... I cannot for the life of me understand the issues fans have with JT. I understand he is not the midline specialty QB and or the get 1 more yard QB. But the general "he cannot run this offense" is beyond understanding.