JacketFromUGA
Helluva Engineer
- Messages
- 4,897
What about Kyle Eckel?
JT and Dedrick place in all-time CPJ team
- Thread starter Gtech50
- Start date
Sideways
Helluva Engineer
- Messages
- 1,589
I agree with almost all of this. I am not sure you can have an all PJ team with only two A backs. Why not more? That said, I would put Orwin, Robbie, and Lynch in with Roddy Jones. Same with B back. Dwyer obviously, then the Davis/Laskey combo (can't have one without the other) and Mills. QB JT5 and Josh N. with honorable mention to Tevin. OT No idea although Andrew Garner and Nick Claytor had the tools. Maybe Marshall or Beano or Erin Joe. I just don't know. Linebackers: Attaochu, Watts, Nealy and Davis DBs White, Sweeting, Jemea Thomas, Morgan, and Isaiah Room for our current two safeties as well.
Special Teams and Present Day Players: Austin twins, (both of them I am not going to start any inter family squabbles) Butker, Golden, Tarrant, Mills, Will, Parker, and possibly Shamire, Apologies to many very fine players whose names I cannot recall but all of whom have contributed to the great tradition of Georgia Tech football.
- Messages
- 3,284
One thing that hasn't been mentioned about the WRs in this discussion is the blocking component being a major factor in who lands where on the all time CPJ era ranking. For this reason alone, I would place BeyBey and Smelter way far clear from the rest of the pack in WR pecking order. Both of those guys would compress your breast bone against your spine with crack blocks and don't think for a minute it doesn't affect safeties when they have to play with their head on a swivel. Our current WRs have worked hard on blocking and have gotten better at doing it downfield, but they don't even come close to instilling palpable fear into opposing safeties. We need that again and it does affect the game.
As far as the rest of it, for me, it is difficult to include current players who are still building a resume into the discussion. For example, I would place Robbie Godhigh and Orwin Smith at the top of the AB heap. But, let's be honest here, Clinton Lynch has built an impressive set of stats thus far in his tenure. However, where he finishes is hard to say. How will the new QB affect his numbers? Could it be that he and JT had a "thing" where they were just on the same page? My sense is that he will continue to be productive because he is an intelligent and savvy player, but I just don't know. The same is true for Mills. All signs appear to be pointing in the right direction, but there is so much water yet to go under the bridge.
JT is finished and his resume complete. Clearly, he belongs as number one QB. The rest are all debatable, and have already been to nauseating degree on this board.
As far as the rest of it, for me, it is difficult to include current players who are still building a resume into the discussion. For example, I would place Robbie Godhigh and Orwin Smith at the top of the AB heap. But, let's be honest here, Clinton Lynch has built an impressive set of stats thus far in his tenure. However, where he finishes is hard to say. How will the new QB affect his numbers? Could it be that he and JT had a "thing" where they were just on the same page? My sense is that he will continue to be productive because he is an intelligent and savvy player, but I just don't know. The same is true for Mills. All signs appear to be pointing in the right direction, but there is so much water yet to go under the bridge.
JT is finished and his resume complete. Clearly, he belongs as number one QB. The rest are all debatable, and have already been to nauseating degree on this board.
FightWinDrink
Helluva Engineer
- Messages
- 2,377
I miss the good old days when someone would have thrown Brad Stewart out there by now and half the forum would explode
Eastman
Helluva Engineer
- Messages
- 1,289
- Location
- Columbia, SC
No way Brad should be ranked higher than second. Now after this year...
I just wish CPJ would have the players race each other or do anything that will give us something fresh to talk about. The season can't get here soon enough.SlawDog
Banned
- Messages
- 295
Him being a 3 year starter as a Junior when many thought he wasn't even worthy of a scolly says everything that needs to be said
Whiskey_Clear
Banned
- Messages
- 10,486
Sneezy is a OLB for the Chargers but played DE for us, at a very high level his last 2 years. Man we have missed that kind of presence off the edge since his departure for the NFL.
These lists, and the glaring differences between the O and D lists, really show the imbalance in talent we have had between those two units. The D has been more lacking in elite level guys.
AE 87
Helluva Engineer
- Messages
- 13,030
Bias. More Defenders have gotten NFL shots.
Whiskey_Clear
Banned
- Messages
- 10,486
BS. How many of those played at elite levels on the field for us? How many panned out in the NFL?
AE 87
Helluva Engineer
- Messages
- 13,030
Well, how they played for us includes D scheme. Just as O includes O scheme.
The same standard of NFL invites/contracts applies to both O players and D players. D has had more.
gtrower
Helluva Engineer
- Messages
- 2,982
Attaochu was an OLB in Groh's 3-4 if I remember correctly.
Whiskey_Clear
Banned
- Messages
- 10,486
Invites and tryouts don't mean a Hill of beans if contracts don't follow. Name one D player who had his talent squandered only to go into the NFL to ball out and prove it. I concede that's a pretty high standard but that seems to be the narrative you are pushing here.
TJ Barnes? Got a contract but I don't think he ever saw any significant playing time. Brandon Watts maybe?
Put Pat Swilling, Marco Coleman, Greg Gathers in any scheme, playing for day DC, and those dudes will ball out and stand out...period.
All this is a digression of my original point that I may not have made clear enough. I'm not saying we have had zero difference makers on that side. We just haven't enjoyed the luxury of having multiple elite level guys performing at that level at the same time / same year much. We've had more situations with elite senior playing on same team as a, in the future to be elite, freshman that wont play at that level until he matures to junior / senior year himself. This has not been the case on O except for..... maybe.... 2015.
AE 87
Helluva Engineer
- Messages
- 13,030
I think you misunderstood me.
I was responding to this part of your quote:
These lists, and the glaring differences between the O and D lists, really show the imbalance in talent we have had between those two units.
"Imbalance in talent!" I was not saying that our D had great talent. I was saying that the NFL has found more talent from our D than from our O as worthy of some kind of relationship. Same standard for both units.
Whiskey_Clear
Banned
- Messages
- 10,486
List them and let's compare then. I really think you are over valuing the " NFL relationship."
Jacketman1
Ramblin' Wreck
- Messages
- 601
Yoda
Helluva Engineer
- Messages
- 1,194
- Location
- Hartwell, GA
Timmy B as QB3
thebull35
Jolly Good Fellow
- Messages
- 237
- Location
- Stone Mountain
You cannot be serious....
The guy only set the ACC record for rushing touchdowns by a QB while he was here...
Milwaukee
Banned
- Messages
- 7,277
- Location
- Milwaukee, WI
Linking Mills with JT at this point is _________.
Fill in the blank.
Fill in the blank.
thebull35
Jolly Good Fellow
- Messages
- 237
- Location
- Stone Mountain
Premature
Yoda
Helluva Engineer
- Messages
- 1,194
- Location
- Hartwell, GA
IMHO Byerly would have started over Tevin.