Transfer Portal: Who's Coming and Going (2022 Roster)

[ChristoGT]

. . . or JT Daniels.

 

[bobongo]

Quick went from 0.9789 to 0.8700. Tchio from 0.9545 to 0.8800.

They were rated in high school by how they performed on the field. If they didn't see much action so far in college, I can only surmise the rating services are rating them on the fact they didn't crack the starting lineup. Not disparaging the ratings, but it doesn't seem they would have much more than that to go on.

 

[Oakland]

Would love to get another Offensive tackle and a kicker who can show Aidan the ropes instead of throwing him in as a freshman.

This offensive lineman was All Ivy League, is in the portal, and is from Marietta. Just not a tackle.

 

[Northeast Stinger]

I agree and I think that is the point iceeater and many, if not all, others have been making! We are glad they are here and we are all hopeful that they can contribute in a positive way.

Thank you. That is exactly how the thread was going. I looked at the list and thought two things. 1) It’s a good list on paper. 2) Realistically we will be fortunate if half of them start for us.

All of us are clinging to hope but this list, as good as it might look on paper, does not automatically vault us into Coastal Division Champs.

 

[Northeast Stinger]

They were rated in high school by how they performed on the field. If they didn't see much action so far in college, I can only surmise the rating services are rating them on the fact they didn't crack the starting lineup. Not disparaging the ratings, but it doesn't seem they would have much more than that to go on.

I have always thought the purpose of a high school rating was to rate their potential for effective college play. The higher the star ratings the higher the potential to perform in college. Hence, percentage wise, the higher the “hit rate” is for higher ranked high school athletes. Readjusting a high school ranking after we see a player’s college performance is a “new art” for the services. Can you image Shaq Mason as a graduate transfer? He would have gone from a 2 star high school prospect to a 5 star transfer.

 

[orientalnc]

I look at this list and think about the impact these guys could make:

QB Zach Gibson (Akron) - Probably the #2 qb, but potential for PT is high
RB Hassan Hall (Louisville) - Lots of PT; likely KO and punt returner
RB Jamious Griffin (Withdrew name) - Probaly #1 or #2 RB; I am happy he decided to stay.
TE Luke Benson (Syracuse) - Possible starter
OL Paul Tchio (Clemson) - Rotation guy; future starter
OL Pierce Quick (Alabama) - Rotation guy; future starter
CB Ahmari Harvey (Auburn) - Future starter
S Khari Gee (ND) - Maybe starter this year; future starter for sure

 

[JacketFan137]

I look at this list and think about the impact these guys could make:

QB Zach Gibson (Akron) - Probably the #2 qb, but potential for PT is high
RB Hassan Hall (Louisville) - Lots of PT; likely KO and punt returner
RB Jamious Griffin (Withdrew name) - Probaly #1 or #2 RB; I am happy he decided to stay.
TE Luke Benson (Syracuse) - Possible starter
OL Paul Tchio (Clemson) - Rotation guy; future starter
OL Pierce Quick (Alabama) - Rotation guy; future starter
CB Ahmari Harvey (Auburn) - Future starter
S Khari Gee (ND) - Maybe starter this year; future starter for sure

there’s two spots on the o line likely vacating and the 3 remaining are nothing special. i think rotation guy is underselling tchio and quick a lot. would not be surprised to see them playing

 

[bobongo]

I have always thought the purpose of a high school rating was to rate their potential for effective college play. The higher the star ratings the higher the potential to perform in college. Hence, percentage wise, the higher the “hit rate” is for higher ranked high school athletes. Readjusting a high school ranking after we see a player’s college performance is a “new art” for the services. Can you image Shaq Mason as a graduate transfer? He would have gone from a 2 star high school prospect to a 5 star transfer.

Shaq Mason's 5-star in the NFL.

 

[MonroeJacket]

there’s two spots on the o line likely vacating and the 3 remaining are nothing special. i think rotation guy is underselling tchio and quick a lot. would not be surprised to see them playing

Right. Barring injuries, I’m looking for those two to start day one. Thought the same about Ken Kirby too though…

 

[orientalnc]

Right. Barring injuries, I’m looking for those two to start day one. Thought the same about Ken Kirby too though…

I certainly hope you guys are correct. We need them to both live up to their 4* rankings from the start. But, Kirby immediately comes to mind and I was dead wrong about him.

 

[bobongo]

I certainly hope you guys are correct. We need them to both live up to their 4* rankings from the start. But, Kirby immediately comes to mind and I was dead wrong about him.

You weren't wrong - he just got injured. Could happen to anybody.

 

[Buzztheirazz]

Is Kirby around another year or is he gone?

 

[MonroeJacket]

Is Kirby around another year or is he gone?

He gone

 

[RamblinRed]

Kirby is gone.

I'm in wait and see on the transfers.
Quick didn't even get off the bench at AL and Tchio played sparingly for Clemson's OL - which was considered one of the weakest units on their team last year.
They may turn out to be starters, but I certainly wouldn't assume that. They don't really have the profile of other OL transfers we have brought in who were immediate starters.

 

[MonroeJacket]

Barring injuries and breakouts from unproven guys, this might be our OL ATL going into week 1.

Jordan Williams 6’6 333
Nick Pendley 6’4 319
Mike Minivan 6’3 300
Pierce Quick 6’5 306
Paul Tchio 6’5 310
Wing Green 6’7 309
Jakiah Leftwich 6’6 327
Weston Franklin 6’4 316
Paula Vaipulu 6’3 303
Will Lay 6’2 313
Mike Maye 6’3 317

*I know this is the transfer thread, so mods move if need be.

 

[LargeFO]

Barring injuries and breakouts from unproven guys, this might be our OL ATL going into week 1.

Jordan Williams 6’6 333
Nick Pendley 6’4 319
Mike Minivan 6’3 300
Pierce Quick 6’5 306
Paul Tchio 6’5 310
Wing Green 6’7 309
Jakiah Leftwich 6’6 327
Weston Franklin 6’4 316
Paula Vaipulu 6’3 303
Will Lay 6’2 313
Mike Maye 6’3 317

*I know this is the transfer thread, so mods move if need be.

Looks pretty good. I might include Spiers(sp) too.

 

[4shotB]

Barring injuries and breakouts from unproven guys, this might be our OL ATL going into week 1.

Jordan Williams 6’6 333
Nick Pendley 6’4 319
Mike Minivan 6’3 300
Pierce Quick 6’5 306
Paul Tchio 6’5 310
Wing Green 6’7 309
Jakiah Leftwich 6’6 327
Weston Franklin 6’4 316
Paula Vaipulu 6’3 303
Will Lay 6’2 313
Mike Maye 6’3 317

*I know this is the transfer thread, so mods move if need be.

There is enough size and experience on that list such that A) it appears we have the pieces now to be a lot better than what we have seen and B) it is not necessary that we automatically start the transfers out of desperation. If they beat out the guys in front of them then that's fine. But they don't have to be our starters and can just provide depth (it's rare when we have THAT!).

 

[orientalnc]

This is interesting. We will have a very young OL in 2022 and that does not bode especially well. Or, are we old enough?

Jordan Williams 6’6 333 Soph
Nick Pendley 6’4 319 R-Soph
Mike Minivan 6’3 300 R-Sr
Pierce Quick 6’5 306 R-Soph
Paul Tchio 6’5 310 Soph
Wing Green 6’7 309 R-Fr
Jakiah Leftwich 6’6 327 R-Fr
Weston Franklin 6’4 316 Soph
Paula Vaipulu 6’3 303 Soph
Will Lay 6’2 313 R-Sr
Mike Maye 6’3 317 R-Jr

 

[LargeFO]

This is interesting. We will have a very young OL in 2022 and that does not bode especially well. Or, are we old enough?

Jordan Williams 6’6 333 Soph
Nick Pendley 6’4 319 R-Soph
Mike Minivan 6’3 300 R-Sr
Pierce Quick 6’5 306 R-Soph
Paul Tchio 6’5 310 Soph
Wing Green 6’7 309 R-Fr
Jakiah Leftwich 6’6 327 R-Fr
Weston Franklin 6’4 316 Soph
Paula Vaipulu 6’3 303 Soph
Will Lay 6’2 313 R-Sr
Mike Maye 6’3 317 R-Jr

Fairly young. Although Williams is really a true junior in terms of game experience right?

 

[JacketOff2]

This is interesting. We will have a very young OL in 2022 and that does not bode especially well. Or, are we old enough?

Jordan Williams 6’6 333 Soph
Nick Pendley 6’4 319 R-Soph
Mike Minivan 6’3 300 R-Sr
Pierce Quick 6’5 306 R-Soph
Paul Tchio 6’5 310 Soph
Wing Green 6’7 309 R-Fr
Jakiah Leftwich 6’6 327 R-Fr
Weston Franklin 6’4 316 Soph
Paula Vaipulu 6’3 303 Soph
Will Lay 6’2 313 R-Sr
Mike Maye 6’3 317 R-Jr

I think this is a bit misleading because of the extra Covid year. Everybody on this list outside of Franklin and Leftwich will be in at least their 3rd year on campus, which would effectively make all of them juniors or redshirt sophomores. 3 of the projected starters (Pendlay, Minihan, Quick) will be in their 4th year or older, and Jordan Williams has already been a starter for 2 years. There should be plenty of experience, maturity, and talent to field a competent OL, one that’s at least average for an FBS team. If there’s not then there’s some serious issues up top with that group