Deleted member 2897
Guest
"You are academically gifted. We award you this scholarship based on your academics."
"Sorry, your academics were not as good as we'd hoped, we must revoke your scholarship."
"You are athletically gifted. We award you this scholarship based on your athletic ability."
"Sorry, your athletics were not as good as we'd hoped, but you get to keep your scholarship."
See the difference?
Apples and oranges. Someone getting poor grades is not analogous to a player getting injured or drastic changes in schemes. Sure, they might also have never developed straight up as a player, but even that to me is different