AE 87
Helluva Engineer
- Messages
- 13,030
No I did not. That ok with you?
Yeah, sorry, no problem.
No I did not. That ok with you?
Not sure what year this changed, but if my wife knows the rule so it’s certainly not an obscure rule. It just reeks of inexperience & the type of problem that you go thru when you try to fleet up a newbie that’s not quite ready to go yet. If it’s the harsh alternative, we’re in for a rough run.I just watched your link multiple times & have attempted a transcript of what the ref said:
"Prior to the stap, snap infraction #55 offense. This foul occurred under 1 minute to play the second half with game clock running. By rule, this equals a 10 second runoff. Clock operator, reset the clock to 13 seconds and restart at READY FOR PLAY."
It was very clear on the radio.One more time. I went back and watch the last series. Here is what happened.
After the 34 second mark on 3rd and 12 to go, the Defensive player went down with an injury. The ref announced and I could hear it very clearly on the telecast, “the clock will start on the snap.”
And it did start on the snap and we made the first down. Then came the penalty , after some confusion and a lot of crowd noise you could barely hear the ref say but he did say “and clock operator start on the ready to play“
So the ref got it right and the clock operator did start the clock on the ready to play.
So I think what everybody has in their head is the first announcement from the ref that was loud and clear - that the clock started on the snap.
The second announcement after our penalty was very hard to hear over the telecast and in the stadium apparently.
Anyway that’s what happened.
You are correct, This what should have happened.It should not have gotten to that point. He should have called the timeout at 23 seconds to avoid the runoff and extend the game. Even if he screwed that rule up. It should not have mattered
One more time. I went back and watch the last series. Here is what happened.
Link at 20:41. Am I mishearing, or did the referee clearly state that the clock operator should restart the clock at the signal for ready for play? If so, why did Collins state in his press conference that the referee stated the clock would start at the snap? Collins was adamant in the press conference that the referee announced to the stadium that the clock would start at the snap; this clip seems to indicate otherwise.
I remember sitting about 20 rows up from the sideline at the 50 (moved there from upper deck cause there were so many holes) and I remember hearing "on the snap" as well. I think there was the penalty, but there was also a Citadel player that went down (to slow down our tempo). I think there was a media timeout somewhere in the last minute or so, which I thought was due to the injured player. If the clock was stopped for the injured player, then it starts back on the snap right?Sitting maybe 35 yards from the ref and the speaker it sounded like SNAP. All of section 101 heard SNAP.
I wonder if they came to him after the penalty and were asking if he wanted to burn the TO to avoid the 10 second runoff, then the clock would start on the snap. He obviously declined to use the TO, but maybe "on the snap" was still in his head.On the game broadcast the official clearly said to start the clock on the ready for play. What I'm wondering is if at some point during the discussions that Collins was having with the refs before that announcement was made (you could see on the broadcast one of the officials come over and talk to Collins) that the official said it would start on the snap. The only reason I even consider that instead of concluding that Collins misheard (which is entirely possible, potentially even probable) is that when he was asked the question the press conference he told the reporter, Kelly I think, to say what the ref had said. And Kelly said that the ref said it would start on the snap. So that's why I'm so confused. On the TV broadcast the official was quite clear that it would start on the ready for play. But someone else besides Collins also heard from the officials that it would start on the snap. At least that's what I thought was said in the press conference.
Where your QB would have more speed and time to pick the right hole coming down hill? Real popular but it’s usually called a QB Draw when out of shotgun.Ok, try a qb sneak from shotgun.
Where your QB would have more speed and time to pick the right hole coming down hill? Real popular but it’s usually called a QB Draw when out of shotgun.
Please tell me what offensive he’s suppose to choose?