They pass the eyeball test playing a bunch of really bad teams with only one good team that almost beat them? I don't know about that. In a normal year I would say OSU should get in, but this year they absolutely don't deserve to on principle that they have played HALF the games everyone else has, and a weaker schedule. How is that fair?
Personally, I agree with you. That is not the same as predicting what will happen.
If Bama wins the SEC:
Bama will be undefeated and SEC Champs
A&M will have lost one game
Florida will have lost two games
If Florida wins the SEC:
Florida will have one loss and SEC Champs
Bama will have one loss (to Florida)
A&M will have one loss (to Bama)
If ND and Clemson are both in the CFP, A&M looks a lot better if Bama wins than if Florida wins. That changes (a lot) if Clemson has two losses.
But, would the CFP committee see a third place SEC team as a better invitee than undefeated tOSU (even with only 5 games)? It will be interesting.
My other prediction is the Jets will have to win the Super Bowl before uGA gets invited.