Should Hall Retire? (Poll)

Should Hall retire?

  • Yes, when he is ready.

    Votes: 21 16.9%

  • Yes, he should be retired at the end of the season.

    Votes: 91 73.4%

  • No, he should be fired.

    Votes: 7 5.6%

  • No, baseball at GT doesn't matter.

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • No, not as long as he has the support of past MLB players who contribute a lot.

    Votes: 5 4.0%
  • Total voters
    124
Killerbees

Killerbees

Jolly Good Fellow
Messages
197
For the younger guys, an 18 year old can be dominant against 15-18 year olds in high school, but likely many will not have near the same success against college kids who average 21+ years of age with 3 + years in college baseball under there belts. I agree with the comment above about the set up strategy being crucial for success. Obviously easier said than done but it makes sense. Also if you followed any of our guys in high school you will notice the pitch selection that made them successful is not the same selection they are being asked to throw in college. Learning new pitches takes time. Again, maybe this is great for college/MLB development, but unfortunately we don’t have a minor league system in college to take those beatings.
 

griffin mizell

Georgia Tech Fan
Messages
54
Quietman6520 said:
Thank you for proving impermissible benefits. I know the big Organizations provide airfare and accommodations for certain kids while they are playing. Does not receiving these benefits before college void your amateur status ? Seems pretty straight forward to me. My point is this. The recruiters are beholding to these organizations more so than you realize. They direct kids to certain schools. They tell xyz school " I'll send you Johnny but you'll have to take Joe too ". And these types of deals are hard to break once you go down that road. I played baseball at GT and won 2 acc titles. I sent a recruit to Tech a few years back and he won an acc title. That's 3 of the 9 titles Tech has in their history. From my perspective, I don't like what Tech has become. Russ Chandler is one of the most beautiful ballparks in the country with the latest technology and yet we can't fill it up ? People want to see teams that play unselfishly and for each other with passion.
Click to expand...
amen
 

griffin mizell

Georgia Tech Fan
Messages
54
Quietman6520 said:
Let's start by saying that Russ Chandler is not a pitcher friendly park. A starting pitcher that can accomplish a 4.5 ERA for Tech would be sufficient to win a lot of games at Tech. You need contrast in pitching styles to accomplish this effectively. For example, if all my starters throw 92-94 and are RH there's a pretty good chance that even if the 1st starter is successful that the next 2 will not be. If Tech recruited a RHP that threw 78-80 mph but threw lots of cutters and maybe 2 or 3 different curves at varying speeds they would be crushed in recruiting rankings because this player would not be ranked. In today's world hitters train to hit velo and have lots of problems adjusting. This type of pitcher would set up your 92-94 RHP to be very successful in the next start. Most prospective Pitchers are identified early on by velo only. They are ranked higher as a result of arm strength not pitchability. I've personally seen 3 Tech pitching recruits in the past couple of years and they all had common traits. They all threw hard 92-94mph but with very little command of the fastball and no ability to throw offspeed for consistent strikes and certainly lacked the ability to throw the offspeed when behind in the count. These type of recruits are dangerous because they often arrive on campus injured and can't help your team or they can't unlearn how they've always pitched and have very unsuccessful Tech baseball careers. BTW I'm not a fan of the shift in baseball. Nothing more deflating for your pitcher than a routine ground ball getting thru because of a shift.
Click to expand...
amen again
 

GTRambler

Helluva Engineer
Messages
1,622
I forgot to add one more thing that my son-in-law said to me about his baseball recruiting efforts in general:

“I’m forced to recruit the leftovers.”

In other words: he’s a Division III baseball coach. LOL
 

GTJon

Jolly Good Fellow
Messages
165
GTRambler said:
My son-in-law, who is the head coach of a Divsion III baseball team, tells me that far too many high school pitchers pitch too much and throw their arms off, especially when they play travel ball during the summers when school is out.
Click to expand...
Not entirely related to this discussion, but your comment made me think of this.

My son is just an average kid in the local park league. However, his team's best pitcher certainly seems like he could be special. Mom played college softball, dad played college baseball. The ball just sounds different when his pitches hit the catcher's mitt. Good control, nice movement. He pitches on our team as well as 2 different travel teams. Now suddenly his arm is hurting and parents are taking him to a specialist out of the area.

Oh, and he's in 3rd grade.
 
eokerholm

eokerholm

Helluva Engineer
Messages
1,592
Oh they must have gotten worse. This was as of Friday
https://www.ncaa.com/stats/baseball/d1/current/team/211/p5
1682971463107.png


1682971554187.png
 
TampaBuzz

TampaBuzz

Helluva Engineer
Messages
1,168
CTJacket said:
I get what you're saying but firing a baseball coach midseason without cause is extremely rare if not unheard of.
Click to expand...
Isn't a pitching staff rated 230 out of 295 appropriate "cause"? Isn't 18 walks in a single game appropriate "cause"? If we can fire a head football coach mid-season, we can sure as hell fire a pitching coach mid-season. In my opinion...our pitching coach is good at getting folks to throw hard with high spin; but lacks skill at teaching folks how to throw strikes, change speeds and actually get people out. I also wonder how much attention (any?) is being paid to the mental aspect to pitching?
 
CTJacket

CTJacket

Ramblin' Wreck
Messages
532
LargeFO said:
I was fine with the offseason last year.
Click to expand...
Clearly, esp with hindsight, it should have been done. Even in the 'moment' it had merit based on results. Sometimes the resume just doesn't pan out the way you think it will (see Groh, Al).

Regardless of what happens with CDH, I expect Borrell to be given his walking papers this offseason barring some miraculous pitching upswing.
 
GTNavyNuke

GTNavyNuke

Helluva Engineer
Featured Member
Messages
10,063
Location
Williamsburg Virginia
TampaBuzz said:
Isn't a pitching staff rated 230 out of 295 appropriate "cause"? Isn't 18 walks in a single game appropriate "cause"? If we can fire a head football coach mid-season, we can sure as hell fire a pitching coach mid-season. In my opinion...our pitching coach is good at getting folks to throw hard with high spin; but lacks skill at teaching folks how to throw strikes, change speeds and actually get people out. I also wonder how much attention (any?) is being paid to the mental aspect to pitching?
Click to expand...

Comparing us to MSU doesn't make sense. Baseball matters a lot at MSU; in 2022 they were third in attendance at 10,289 average attendance. We were at 1506 average. http://fs.ncaa.org/Docs/stats/baseball_RB/2023/attend.pdf

That's why we have the talent coming in without commensurate results being tolerated.

I just changed my vote to Baseball Doesn't Matter at GT.
 
LargeFO

LargeFO

Helluva Engineer
Messages
3,418
GTNavyNuke said:
Comparing us to MSU doesn't make sense. Baseball matters a lot at MSU; in 2022 they were third in attendance at 10,289 average attendance. We were at 1506 average. http://fs.ncaa.org/Docs/stats/baseball_RB/2023/attend.pdf

That's why we have the talent coming in without commensurate results being tolerated.

I just changed my vote to Baseball Doesn't Matter at GT.
Click to expand...

I mean I sadly don’t think you’re wrong with what leadership has shown us this last decade+. See if Batt/Cabrera wanna make it matter again this offseason. We’ve been in Danny-cruising-leave-when-he-wants mode for way too long.
 
Buzzbomb

Buzzbomb

Mello Yellow-Jacket
Messages
12,014
If CDH doesn’t retire or take a Coach Cremins type of buy-out, will he can our pitching coach? Tech has given up 50 hits more than any of the other ACC teams.
 
Top