stech81
Helluva Engineer
- Messages
- 8,961
- Location
- Woodstock Georgia
People recruiting means 0 till they sign. It takes 3 years to see if a recruiting class is good or poor. Fill your need coach them up.
Total points are a measurement of number. meaning size of class along with star ratings.First, this formatting gave me a brain aneurysm. Second, you've put the total points for each class on here completely ruining your side of the argument. Rivals only uses points for the top 20 recruits. 1621 > 1374. /thread
So just to be real with it, this current recruiting class is graded the same as our 2018 class according to rivals. Average 3.0. So it plans out like I have been saying.
No we have 2 more. SOOOO all three stars are not equal.....I just find the whole recruiting thing a joke. It is scheme and coaching that matters. Ask Miami.You’re wrong. Look at the point difference. We currently have 1 more recruit in 2020 but 250 more points.
No we have 2 more. SOOOO all three stars are not equal.....I just find the whole recruiting thing a joke. It is scheme and coaching that matters. Ask Miami.
This is what we will find out over the next few years, because from what I've seen so far, CGC and his coaches can materially out-recruit what we've been used to over the last 10-12 years. But there's more to it than that. Its not fair to say they aren't as good of coaches as CPJ was although it may appear so...but even if you take that to be true for now as an assumption, does having significantly better rated players more than offset that? That's I think what we may find out over time. The SEC is littered with teams who have top 25-rated recruiting classes year after year and never amount to much.
Total points are a measurement of number. meaning size of class along with star ratings.
What is the "team rankings" formula?
Rivals Rating points for a team's Top 20 rated commits + Rivals250 Bonus Points = Total Points
??????total points is total Rivals point assigned by player and then added up based on number of players. Class ranking varies on size of class times point value. Which is why ranking classes is silly because as an example one year we were 84th, Why, because we only needed 14 recruits. We were 84th. Average star 2.71. CSU was ranked ahead of us with 26 recruits average star 2.12
No we have 2 more. SOOOO all three stars are not equal.....I just find the whole recruiting thing a joke. It is scheme and coaching that matters. Ask Miami.
You still don’t get it, so keep pushing false info.
No I’ll just ask the other 20 teams in the Top 25 with 3 losses or less.
So if you are implying it is all about recruiting.....Well let's ask number 25 Navy about that. Or SMU, K State, Baylor, Wake Forest. If you go down the Top 25 you find a lot of really good coaches.You still don’t get it, so keep pushing false info.
No I’ll just ask the other 20 teams in the Top 25 with 3 losses or less.
Sure, getting some player matters but recruiting rankings were created to fill up the offseason. Back in the 70's and the 80's you might hear about one or two good players coming in but the rest you knew nothing about. Coaching and development out does recruiting. Give me a three star at 22 who I have built up over a 5 star freshman any day. That is why heavily senior laden teams win, as long as the coaching is there. Go back and Watch the 2006 ACCG. I promise you we had better stars than Wake Forest, but they had 18 seniors who were starters. Calvin Johnson was nothing that day.You are arguing with someone who literally thinks recruiting doesn't matter. There is no point arguing with him.
So if you are implying it is all about recruiting.....Well let's ask number 25 Navy about that. Or SMU, K State, Baylor, Wake Forest. If you go down the Top 25 you find a lot of really good coaches.
How many transfers did Navy get. And I bet right now they would kick our butts. Ask the Citadel.You should really stop
SMU transfers:
Shane Buechele: https://n.rivals.com/content/prospects/2016/shane-buechele-3673
Cam’Ron Jones: https://n.rivals.com/content/prospects/2018/cam-jones-170008
Chevin Calloway https://n.rivals.com/content/prospects/2017/chevin-calloway-139
Thomas Shelmire
https://n.rivals.com/content/prospects/2018/thomas-shelmire-181181
https://247sports.com/college/smu/L...football-transfers-new-players-134499064/Amp/
Sure, getting some player matters but recruiting rankings were created to fill up the offseason. Back in the 70's and the 80's you might hear about one or two good players coming in but the rest you knew nothing about. Coaching and development out does recruiting. Give me a three star at 22 who I have built up over a 5 star freshman any day. That is why heavily senior laden teams win, as long as the coaching is there. Go back and Watch the 2006 ACCG. I promise you we had better stars than Wake Forest, but they had 18 seniors who were starters. Calvin Johnson was nothing that day.
How many transfers did Navy get. And I bet right now they would kick our butts. Ask the Citadel.
Did you see his kickoff attempt yesterday and his missed XP earlier in the season? Watched him in warmups? Wells is simply not right at all presently, whether it is an injury or something else. They arent sitting him for no reason.
Navy is 25 in the nation. They are ranked.wHAt ABouT navY?