Deleted member 2897
Guest
Until the kicker gets arrested for shooting up the dorm or smoking pot, and actually puts some points on the board for The Fulmer Cup, he's not really a part of the team.
"no schollarship for you.....'' kirby smart
- Thread starter gtpi
- Start date
techman33908
Georgia Tech Fan
- Messages
- 20
Don't worry Dad,Kirby won't be there long
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
COJacket
Ramblin' Wreck
- Messages
- 794
- Location
- Colorado Springs, CO
I read in another article on STs that UGA was struggling w FGs until this kid got a chance part way through the season to start kicking That writer gave the kid a lot of credit for turning this area around from a real weakness to a strength
dressedcheeseside
Helluva Engineer
- Messages
- 14,045
I think CPJ has it right. If a walkon makes the 2 deep and participates regularly, they get a scholly. They've earned it. I think it's outrageous to expect a starter to pay his own way. RB should transfer as soon as he can find any school that will offer a scholly.
Since he's a walkon, does he have to sit out a year if he transfers?
I think Smart is being dumb as this gives a negative incentive for any other talented kids to walk on at the cesspool. Good for GT! Maybe we can gain from Smart's blunder and pick up some talented walkons that would have gone to Ugag.
Since he's a walkon, does he have to sit out a year if he transfers?
I think Smart is being dumb as this gives a negative incentive for any other talented kids to walk on at the cesspool. Good for GT! Maybe we can gain from Smart's blunder and pick up some talented walkons that would have gone to Ugag.
Supersizethatorder-mutt
Banned
- Messages
- 13,443
- Location
- Augusta, GA
That all may be true, but one additional thought I have is what's with this "scholarship for the spring semester"? At Tech we give scholarships for 4 years (or until completion of eligibility) not one semester or one year scholarships. I am proud to be a fan of a program that puts the STUDENT-athlete first.
- Messages
- 11,504
- Location
- Marietta, GA
gtpi
Helluva Engineer
- Messages
- 1,642
- Location
- BFE , south carolina
good post. imo we dont acknowledge cpj and all the intangibles he brings to our program.
1. he graduates most of his players.
2. we seldom have fulmer cup issues.
3. he treats the players with respect.
thanks coach.
takethepoints
Helluva Engineer
- Messages
- 5,901
Well, isn't that special?
This clearly shows that he learned something from Nick Saban, doesn't it? Yes, The Great Satan is really good at holding every scholarship for players he thinks will work out in their last two years. Little things like on-field performance and saving football games shouldn't count for much in comparison to that.
Next Kirby will be chasing scholarship football players off when he thinks they won't work out so he can game the numbers. After all, that's why the Dwags hired him: to get them to an NC, no matter what the costs. And now we have a preview of how the collection of nimrods they call a "fan base" will try to justify that. Exciting, isn't it?
This clearly shows that he learned something from Nick Saban, doesn't it? Yes, The Great Satan is really good at holding every scholarship for players he thinks will work out in their last two years. Little things like on-field performance and saving football games shouldn't count for much in comparison to that.
Next Kirby will be chasing scholarship football players off when he thinks they won't work out so he can game the numbers. After all, that's why the Dwags hired him: to get them to an NC, no matter what the costs. And now we have a preview of how the collection of nimrods they call a "fan base" will try to justify that. Exciting, isn't it?
gtpi
Helluva Engineer
- Messages
- 1,642
- Location
- BFE , south carolina
as i see it. the comments here are a reflection of who was elected. many people seem to think that its all about success. 'so what that you dont honor your contracts or word.'
'so what. im a fan. im a stock holder.' wins and losses... the bottom line is what's important these days to many.
maybe its just me. maybe im out of touch. when i grew up they also taught courses in business ethics. the ceo to worker pay ratio was 24:1 . now its closer to 500:1. i was lucky. i ran into only one 'saban' as a boss until i got into corporate management. his business failed.
the current trend in unethical behavior is the big reason why i retired early. integrity is something i value highly. ie doing the RIGHT thing when nobody is watching. i try to live by it daily.
smart got caught not being so smart imo. if i was a kicker i would avoid uga like the plague.
as far as the letter goes. i hope this encourages other parents / players to come out of the wood work. we all complain about this behavior on sports blogs but some dont want it exposed.
its never gonna fix itself. afterall... you cant fix what you dont acknowledge.
'so what. im a fan. im a stock holder.' wins and losses... the bottom line is what's important these days to many.
maybe its just me. maybe im out of touch. when i grew up they also taught courses in business ethics. the ceo to worker pay ratio was 24:1 . now its closer to 500:1. i was lucky. i ran into only one 'saban' as a boss until i got into corporate management. his business failed.
the current trend in unethical behavior is the big reason why i retired early. integrity is something i value highly. ie doing the RIGHT thing when nobody is watching. i try to live by it daily.
smart got caught not being so smart imo. if i was a kicker i would avoid uga like the plague.
as far as the letter goes. i hope this encourages other parents / players to come out of the wood work. we all complain about this behavior on sports blogs but some dont want it exposed.
its never gonna fix itself. afterall... you cant fix what you dont acknowledge.
Last edited:
OldJacketFan
Helluva Engineer
- Messages
- 8,348
- Location
- Nashville, TN
Yes he did and he is working with the team/coaches as a, for lack of a better term, coaching aide.
- Messages
- 9,904
- Location
- Williamsburg Virginia
jeffgt14
We don't quite suck as much anymore.
- Messages
- 5,789
- Location
- Mt Juliet, TN
??? I don't see anything Kirby did wrong here. You can argue whether you think he deserves a scholarship or not but there's really not anything Kirby did wrong. He's the head coach and chooses where his scholarships go. If he chooses to not give a walk-on kicker a scholarship then he doesn't have to. He made his choice and if Rodrigo doesn't like it and feels he can get a scholarship somewhere else and play then he has the right to do so and it's Kirby's loss (if any). The dad's the one that needs to chill out. Unless he's really just stirring stuff up to "market" his son to other school's like Techster mentioned earlier, then what he's doing is pretty damn petty.
gtpi
Helluva Engineer
- Messages
- 1,642
- Location
- BFE , south carolina
its a moral thing. kinda like all the cities banning feeding the homeless while the cops take their blankets and possessions.
ITS THE LAW but the behavior is not ethical nor moral.
alentrekin
Ramblin' Wreck
- Messages
- 876
- Location
- California
It's clearly also the dad's loss of money -- had it, now it's UGA's -- as well. Whether you, K-SMART or anyone thinks that is justified or immoral is a different question, about which some of us have strong opinions.
jeffgt14
We don't quite suck as much anymore.
- Messages
- 5,789
- Location
- Mt Juliet, TN
That doesn’t even relate. Homeless people are… homeless. This kid did not get a scholarship taken away from him nor was ever promised one. Sure maybe he thought he could kick well and end up on a scholarship but at the end of the day, Kirby decided he wants to use his ships elsewhere. I don’t care who the player is or what school they go to. If he feels he deserves a scholarship and doesn’t get it, go somewhere else. It’s the same as any employee who feels they didn’t get the raise or bonus they deserve. Go somewhere that’ll give you one. Not getting a scholarship is in no way Rodrigo’s “loss”. He performed. Others saw. Put yourself on the market because UGA doesn’t want you. Kirby’s loss.
PBR549
Ramblin' Wreck
- Messages
- 837
Doesn't relate. If you feel he's being wronged feel free to send him some money.
AE 87
Helluva Engineer
- Messages
- 13,016
Oh, I think you're over thinking it. No one denies that Kirby has the right. Just as the dad has the right to express his disagreement.
The question is whether folks agree with one or the other.
Whiskey_Clear
Banned
- Messages
- 10,486
https://www.dawgnation.com/football...il-carters-loss-may-rodrigo-blankenships-gain
http://onlineathens.com/sports/2016...-uga-scholarship-offer-kirby-smart-insists-we
Kicker's dad may be a putz but Smart is at home in the Saban trained cesspool. Where pulled scholly offers and "gray shirts" don't count as pulling offers. If Smart had shot straight with either one of these players he wouldn't have a mess on his hands. Not much of a mess as most mutt fans only moral is "jest win baby".
jeffgt14
We don't quite suck as much anymore.
- Messages
- 5,789
- Location
- Mt Juliet, TN
Dropping kids is a different issue. I agree with you there.