Coronavirus Thread

  • Thread starter Deleted member 2897
  • Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.

GT_EE78

Banned
Messages
3,605
The next $500B package just passed Congress, with 6 of the 100 Senators voting. :D

We may have a really really good number today in the US on new cases. We're at 17k right now. We may finish in the low 20ks, a number we haven't seen in 3 weeks.
That's interesting. worldometers is showing 27K. I'd guess this indicates that the counters reset at different times with two day totals about identical.
 

RamblinRed

Helluva Engineer
Featured Member
Messages
5,850
Last word for me on undercounting.
The Governor of NY today mentioned in his PC that they know they are undercounting.
The current estimates by statisticians is around 60% for NY. Nate Silver's twitter feed has excellent discussion on looking at undercounting world wide.

Also, the Georgia Public Health Department in its noon release today mentioned this
"Officials say those numbers are lagging as data rolls in from local officials and hospitals and do not reflect the crisis in real time"

I'd also like to once again recommend Nate Silver's twitter feed and his site fivethirtyeight.com. Great site to go to if you love numbers. They do everything from sports to politics to culture.
This is an excellent new article by Nate on the crisis across the country and how it is getting better in some places and worse in others. I'll also mention since it is looking at positive test rates that it is generally considered that testing should show less than a 10% positive rate before a place is in a spot where it can control further outbreaks.
https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/coronavirus-cases-are-still-growing-in-many-u-s-states/

Also, from that site is an excellent article on reading charts and all the various items you have to look for and take into account.
https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/one-chart-isnt-going-to-tell-you-when-the-pandemic-peaked/
 

RonJohn

Helluva Engineer
Messages
4,990
Will the virus "die out" come summer? I have no idea how reputable this source is generally, but these look like verifiable stats. Make of it what you will.

https://outragedpatriot.com/new-data-on-covid-19-liberal-media-refuses-to-report/

It is a highly biased interpretation of some data. They say that the death rate per million is higher in Northern states than Southern states, but the chart they show lists Louisiana as the fourth highest deaths per million. In Florida, the great majority of all cases in the state are from Miami to West Palm Beach. That area of the country has been as warm and humid for the last few weeks as parts of the country will be in the summer. It is summer in Brazil, and they have cases, and apparently issues containing it. If it dies out by itself in the summer, then Brazil wouldn't be having to take any measures to contain it.

There might be some seasonality to the virus. There isn't any data anywhere that proves there is. There isn't any data anywhere that proves that heat and humidity prevent infection. In fact, Brazil is proof that it can and does spread in hot and humid environments. There are various hypothesis about why flu is seasonal. One idea is that the extra humidity causes the virus to stay in the air less time, as droplets with the virus collect water from the air and drop faster. Another is that people are inside, and closer to other people more in the winter. Both of those have been proven to be true, but nobody has been able to prove whether one of those factors, both of those factors, or neither are the main reason for flu seasonality. With COVID-19, there is much less data than there is about flu. It is not reasonable to expect that anyone actually knows for sure what will happen.
 

GTNavyNuke

Helluva Engineer
Featured Member
Messages
10,057
Location
Williamsburg Virginia
Will the virus "die out" come summer? I have no idea how reputable this source is generally, but these look like verifiable stats. Make of it what you will.

https://outragedpatriot.com/new-data-on-covid-19-liberal-media-refuses-to-report/

As @RonJohn just posted. No it won't "die out". Singapore, indonesia, mecca, new Orleans all examples that say not.

But is it less in warm weather? Yes the transmission rate probably goes down due to less suspension time in the air. At least that's what the flu dying out in the summer is thought to be due to, at least partly. COVID-19 is just way more infectious.
 

jacketup

Helluva Engineer
Messages
1,551
The polio vaccine took years to develop, but, as horrible as polio was (much worse than Covid), we never shut down the country.

And rampant tuberculosis when we were kids. There were dedicated hospitals for it. We didn't shut the country down.

I am saddened by what is going on in this country. Some delusion among modern US society that life is without risk. A belief that Government can provide all our needs and perfect security.

This is earth, not heaven. And the US Government is not God.

If WWII was fought today, we would lose. That may be what the Russians and/or Chinese are hoping for.
 

MWBATL

Helluva Engineer
Messages
6,509
This is sarcasm, right? Tell me you don’t really believe that. Krugman has been wrong more often than the local weatherman....
It isn't me, it's DeLong with his tongue in cheek. He actually disagrees with Krugman fairly often. His problem is that Krugman is usually able to dispose of his objections pretty quickly.

But I don't know where you get the idea that Krugman is wrong very often. When it comes to economic questions, he is usually right and he seldom spouts off on anything else. Of course, when he does he's no better then the rest of us. Now, if what you means is that you disagree with him, that's another matter. But that, of course, has nothing to do with whether or not Krugman's right.[/QUOTE]
Well, there's this for starters:
By PAUL KRUGMAN

COMMENT2016-11-09T00:42:44-05:0012:42 AM ET
It really does now look like President Donald J. Trump, and markets are plunging. When might we expect them to recover?

Frankly, I find it hard to care much, even though this is my specialty. The disaster for America and the world has so many aspects that the economic ramifications are way down my list of things to fear.

Still, I guess people want an answer: If the question is when markets will recover, a first-pass answer is never.
 
Messages
13,443
Location
Augusta, GA
It is a highly biased interpretation of some data. They say that the death rate per million is higher in Northern states than Southern states, but the chart they show lists Louisiana as the fourth highest deaths per million. In Florida, the great majority of all cases in the state are from Miami to West Palm Beach. That area of the country has been as warm and humid for the last few weeks as parts of the country will be in the summer. It is summer in Brazil, and they have cases, and apparently issues containing it. If it dies out by itself in the summer, then Brazil wouldn't be having to take any measures to contain it.

There might be some seasonality to the virus. There isn't any data anywhere that proves there is. There isn't any data anywhere that proves that heat and humidity prevent infection. In fact, Brazil is proof that it can and does spread in hot and humid environments. There are various hypothesis about why flu is seasonal. One idea is that the extra humidity causes the virus to stay in the air less time, as droplets with the virus collect water from the air and drop faster. Another is that people are inside, and closer to other people more in the winter. Both of those have been proven to be true, but nobody has been able to prove whether one of those factors, both of those factors, or neither are the main reason for flu seasonality. With COVID-19, there is much less data than there is about flu. It is not reasonable to expect that anyone actually knows for sure what will happen.
I am not sure exactly how to respond to your post, because you seem to accept some of the things pointed out in the article and ignore others. I will say from the start, however, that I agree with you that nobody knows right now if it is seasonal or not, although there sure seem to be a lot of "experts" saying, or at least implying, that it is. Only time will tell on that matter. Yes, Louisiana has the fourth highest death rate per million in the country (supposedly high, at least in part, because of Mardis Gras), but the AVERAGE number of deaths per million for the warmer Southern border states is 70 deaths per million or 50% of the national average. Meanwhile, the AVERAGE number of deaths per million for the northern New England escalates to 293 deaths per million or 213% of the national average. That could well be attributed to population density, just as for the dense crowds at Louisiana's Mardi Gras celebrations. As far as it spreading in hot and humid environments in the southern hemisphere, yes, it has spread in those countries. Tom Hanks and his wife caught it in Australia. But the article doesn't provide numbers for various countries. It only provides that one map, and if you look at it, it shows by the color green where the virus is most prevalent. The only green areas in the southern hemisphere are western South America, where it is mountainous and mostly cool, if not cold, even during their summer months. As I said from the start, I have no idea how accurate that article is, but to write it off as a "highly biased interpretation of some data," is being rather dismissive on your part. We shall see in the months ahead whether and how much change there will be all over the world as we move from one season to the next, be it cold to hot, or hot to cold. There may be no differences at all, or it could be a complete turnaround from where we are now, if only temporarily. Time will tell.
 

dtm1997

Helluva Engineer
Featured Member
Messages
15,704
I'm in transportation DTM. We have 85 refrigerated trailers that run mainly the southeast. We are based out of Jackson, Ga and 2Q is supposed to be the time we make over half of the companies profits over the course of the year. We haul to a lot to food services that sell to restaurants. As you can imagine, that business has disintegrated into next to nothing over the last month. While I completely understand it will take a while to get back to normal as far as that business goes, every little bit helps and today we have seen the first sings of movement from that portion of our business in a month. For example, a customer needed 4 trucks out of Florida today and that is what he has been using over a 2 week period recently. He said the restaurants opening back up next week has given his business a needed shot in the arm as some are preparing and obviously that trickled over to us.

Thanks. That's an interesting and tricky space to be in right now.

On the one hand, food remains in high demand, but as you point out, so much of it goes to the restaurant supply chain, so the demand on the ground is not absorbing the supply you might support through your business.

Unfortunately, that industry is in for a rationalization, as restaurants fail. That's going to happen regardless.

That said, I think as we look ahead, we'll see some restaurants pivot and we'll see foodservice evolve.

For instance, I've heard situations of restaurants pivoting in to small markets, utilizing their supply chain to provide prepared foods, wine bottles, vegetables, cheeses, etc.

It wouldn't surprise me to see some larger format restaurants further develop their takeout & delivery services, soaking up some capacity, albeit possibly at lower levels. In less populated areas, maybe you get more people choosing to visit restaurants, but those areas are already smaller users of capacity.

I think we're already seeing some local food distributors develop capabilities to go direct to consumer. This capacity will absorb some of the supply.

Finally, I think your services may also be required as some restaurants & food suppliers do more cross country consumer delivery. Like does an Omaha Steaks see an uptick as more people stay home regardless, instead of restaurants, driving them needing more refrigerated shipping? A company like Goldbelly might see accelerated growth and need such services. In the past week, I've shipped food from Katz's Deli in NYC to my mom and she's shipped refrigerated items to me.

As a follow-up, do you serve other industries besides the food supply chain and within the food supply chain, do you have any concentrations towards specific products?
 
Messages
13,443
Location
Augusta, GA
And rampant tuberculosis when we were kids. There were dedicated hospitals for it. We didn't shut the country down.

I am saddened by what is going on in this country. Some delusion among modern US society that life is without risk. A belief that Government can provide all our needs and perfect security.

This is earth, not heaven. And the US Government is not God.

If WWII was fought today, we would lose. That may be what the Russians and/or Chinese are hoping for.
It's for sure the American public as a whole would not have tolerated the draconian measures being instituted today. As bad a man as he proved to be in an overall sense, we need a (cleaned up) Joseph McCarthy today to at least wake up the public as to what's going on.
 

RonJohn

Helluva Engineer
Messages
4,990
I am not sure exactly how to respond to your post, because you seem to accept some of the things pointed out in the article and ignore others. I will say from the start, however, that I agree with you that nobody knows right now if it is seasonal or not, although there sure seem to be a lot of "experts" saying, or at least implying, that it is. Only time will tell on that matter. Yes, Louisiana has the fourth highest death rate per million in the country (supposedly high, at least in part, because of Mardis Gras), but the AVERAGE number of deaths per million for the warmer Southern border states is 70 deaths per million or 50% of the national average. Meanwhile, the AVERAGE number of deaths per million for the northern New England escalates to 293 deaths per million or 213% of the national average. That could well be attributed to population density, just as for the dense crowds at Louisiana's Mardi Gras celebrations. As far as it spreading in hot and humid environments in the southern hemisphere, yes, it has spread in those countries. Tom Hanks and his wife caught it in Australia. But the article doesn't provide numbers for various countries. It only provides that one map, and if you look at it, it shows by the color green where the virus is most prevalent. The only green areas in the southern hemisphere are western South America, where it is mountainous and mostly cool, if not cold, even during their summer months. As I said from the start, I have no idea how accurate that article is, but to write it off as a "highly biased interpretation of some data," is being rather dismissive on your part. We shall see in the months ahead whether and how much change there will be all over the world as we move from one season to the next, be it cold to hot, or hot to cold. There may be no differences at all, or it could be a complete turnaround from where we are now, if only temporarily. Time will tell.

What facts did I ignore? I am ignoring most of the conjecture, because it is only speculation.

I think you misinterpreted the heat map on there. It is a map of temperatures, not of the virus. The point of that map is to highlight the claim that "all cities experiencing significant outbreaks of COVID-19 have very similar winter climates". Except that leaves out Miami and New Orleans.

The AVERAGE number of deaths per million in the Dakotas, Wyoming, Idaho, Nebraska, and Montana is lower than the AVERAGE number of deaths per million in Miami and New Orleans. Maybe the difference is in population density instead of climate.

The article uses small snippets of data to arrive at a conclusion. The fact that the virus is actively spreading in Brazil, which is in the middle of summer right now, the temperature is in the 80s with humidity in the 70s is ignored. If, as according to the article:
This indicates that based on data available, the coronavirus in the US should die out come the hot summer months.
Then it would have died out in Brazil. It would have died out in Miami. The claim is proven false by the fact that the virus is thriving in areas that are already hot and humid.

This virus might be seasonal. Many experts, including Fauci, have said that. However, there is no evidence to date that this virus will be seasonal. There is not a good scientific understanding of why flu is seasonal, so making predictions about a new virus is very speculative. The only "evidence" that this story provides is that the most densely populated area of the US is in a cooler climate zone.
 

GTNavyNuke

Helluva Engineer
Featured Member
Messages
10,057
Location
Williamsburg Virginia
Sometimes pictures are better than words. Irregardless of the transmission rate, the mortality rate, just understand it is a very serious health issue. On a national level COVID19 has been the leading cause of death since April 6th. The top 7 causes of death outside of COVID19 are not infectious diseases. Flu and pneumonia is #8 and in April the daily death rate from COVID19 has been 15X greater than that of the flu.



20200414_CovidweeklydeathsUSv2.jpg


20200420_CovidweeklydeathsNYv4includingNYC.jpg




View attachment 8246

@RamblinRed That last graph is for England and Wales from UK Office of National Statstics. https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopula...landandwalesprovisional/weekending10april2020

Anyone know if there is one for the US?
 
Messages
13,443
Location
Augusta, GA
What facts did I ignore? I am ignoring most of the conjecture, because it is only speculation.

I think you misinterpreted the heat map on there. It is a map of temperatures, not of the virus. The point of that map is to highlight the claim that "all cities experiencing significant outbreaks of COVID-19 have very similar winter climates". Except that leaves out Miami and New Orleans.

The AVERAGE number of deaths per million in the Dakotas, Wyoming, Idaho, Nebraska, and Montana is lower than the AVERAGE number of deaths per million in Miami and New Orleans. Maybe the difference is in population density instead of climate.

The article uses small snippets of data to arrive at a conclusion. The fact that the virus is actively spreading in Brazil, which is in the middle of summer right now, the temperature is in the 80s with humidity in the 70s is ignored. If, as according to the article:
Then it would have died out in Brazil. It would have died out in Miami. The claim is proven false by the fact that the virus is thriving in areas that are already hot and humid.

This virus might be seasonal. Many experts, including Fauci, have said that. However, there is no evidence to date that this virus will be seasonal. There is not a good scientific understanding of why flu is seasonal, so making predictions about a new virus is very speculative. The only "evidence" that this story provides is that the most densely populated area of the US is in a cooler climate zone.
First, if you read the words underneath the map, it says "The green area in the above map is where the virus is currently thriving. It does not do well in hotter and more humid environments." I had/have the same reservations you do about that, since the map actually does show the various temperature zones in the world. I ASSUME that what they are saying is that it is in those colder climate zones that the virus seems to be thriving. And there is no disputing that, other than Louisiana, that is the case in this country, although it is greater in the more densely populated areas of the north east than it is in the wide open spaces of states like ND, SD, Wyoming, and Montana. Florida seems to be in the middle of the rankings, and I have certainly not heard that it is rampant there, not even in the Miami area. Second, it is now Fall in Brazil, not summer, and it is only slightly higher there than in the cooler (even in summer) climes of Peru and Chile. Take a look at the Johns Hopkins dashboards for the activity in all countries on earth, and it is definitely worse in the colder winter climes of the northern hemisphere.
https://gisanddata.maps.arcgis.com/apps/opsdashboard/index.html#/bda7594740fd40299423467b48e9ecf6
 

RonJohn

Helluva Engineer
Messages
4,990
First, if you read the words underneath the map, it says "The green area in the above map is where the virus is currently thriving. It does not do well in hotter and more humid environments." I had/have the same reservations you do about that, since the map actually does show the various temperature zones in the world. I ASSUME that what they are saying is that it is in those colder climate zones that the virus seems to be thriving. And there is no disputing that, other than Louisiana, that is the case in this country, although it is greater in the more densely populated areas of the north east than it is in the wide open spaces of states like ND, SD, Wyoming, and Montana. Florida seems to be in the middle of the rankings, and I have certainly not heard that it is rampant there, not even in the Miami area. Second, it is now Fall in Brazil, not summer, and it is only slightly higher there than in the cooler (even in summer) climes of Peru and Chile. Take a look at the Johns Hopkins dashboards for the activity in all countries on earth, and it is definitely worse in the colder winter climes of the northern hemisphere.
https://gisanddata.maps.arcgis.com/apps/opsdashboard/index.html#/bda7594740fd40299423467b48e9ecf6


Florida has had about 29,000 confirmed cases. About 17.500 of those are in Dade, Broward, and Palm Beach counties. The temperature there is currently in the high 80s low 90s with humidity from the mid 60s to mid 80s. Is Miami in the green section of that map?

You are correct that it is Fall in Brazil, but the temperature is not cool, and the humidity is not low. Where is Brazil on that map? Is it in the green? It is actually about as far into the red as you can possibly go.

It is a huge stretch to determine that since there are many diagnosed cases in more Northern areas, the virus can't survive heat and humidity and will die out during the Summer. That story originally came from the Gateway Pundit, which is a conservative organization. Step back and read the article without "belief". It starts with a solution. Then it finds snippets of facts that fit that solution and ignores facts (even in the same data it is presenting) that do not fit the solution. The wording and phrasing of the article are made to give the impression that if you don't agree with their "solution" then you are stupid.

I don't care if an article is from a conservative organization or a liberal organization. I try to absorb facts from many sources and arrive at my own conclusions. I try to be skeptical of all sources of information. With this story, ask these questions: If the virus can't thrive in warm climate areas, then why is it thriving in New Orleans and Miami? If the virus thrives in cool climates, why is it not thriving in Minneapolis and Milwaukee?
New York has a ton of cases, but look at this map from the CDC:
COVIDbyState.png

Does that match the only in cool climate theory?

As I stated before, it might subside as things warm up, but this article hasn't presented any evidence of that. It makes strongly worded claims, provides some data points that don't really back those claims, and tries to force belief because of how forceful the writing is. To get me to believe something, they should present the data and let me come to my own conclusion. In this case, the data the present doesn't even back their own claims, much less convince me they are correct.
 
Messages
13,443
Location
Augusta, GA
Florida has had about 29,000 confirmed cases. About 17.500 of those are in Dade, Broward, and Palm Beach counties. The temperature there is currently in the high 80s low 90s with humidity from the mid 60s to mid 80s. Is Miami in the green section of that map?

You are correct that it is Fall in Brazil, but the temperature is not cool, and the humidity is not low. Where is Brazil on that map? Is it in the green? It is actually about as far into the red as you can possibly go.

It is a huge stretch to determine that since there are many diagnosed cases in more Northern areas, the virus can't survive heat and humidity and will die out during the Summer. That story originally came from the Gateway Pundit, which is a conservative organization. Step back and read the article without "belief". It starts with a solution. Then it finds snippets of facts that fit that solution and ignores facts (even in the same data it is presenting) that do not fit the solution. The wording and phrasing of the article are made to give the impression that if you don't agree with their "solution" then you are stupid.

I don't care if an article is from a conservative organization or a liberal organization. I try to absorb facts from many sources and arrive at my own conclusions. I try to be skeptical of all sources of information. With this story, ask these questions: If the virus can't thrive in warm climate areas, then why is it thriving in New Orleans and Miami? If the virus thrives in cool climates, why is it not thriving in Minneapolis and Milwaukee?
New York has a ton of cases, but look at this map from the CDC:
View attachment 8255
Does that match the only in cool climate theory?

As I stated before, it might subside as things warm up, but this article hasn't presented any evidence of that. It makes strongly worded claims, provides some data points that don't really back those claims, and tries to force belief because of how forceful the writing is. To get me to believe something, they should present the data and let me come to my own conclusion. In this case, the data the present doesn't even back their own claims, much less convince me they are correct.
If you will remember, I said from the start that I had no idea how reliable that source was, but I DO think it presented some interesting stats. The Johns Hopkins world stats I included in my last response to you is far more factual and yet seems to confirm to some extent what the article I posted said.
 

RonJohn

Helluva Engineer
Messages
4,990
If you will remember, I said from the start that I had no idea how reliable that source was, but I DO think it presented some interesting stats. The Johns Hopkins world stats I included in my last response to you is far more factual and yet seems to confirm to some extent what the article I posted said.

I don't dispute that there are more confirmed cases in more Northern areas. However, there can be many more factors involved in that than the climate: Access to testing, population densities, population diversity, population access to travel, etc. That is not proof that the virus cannot live in warm climates.

BTW, I looked up the Winter climate in Rio. Since it is in a tropical zone, the temperature drops all the way down to 70F in the Winter.
 
Messages
13,443
Location
Augusta, GA
I don't dispute that there are more confirmed cases in more Northern areas. However, there can be many more factors involved in that than the climate: Access to testing, population densities, population diversity, population access to travel, etc. That is not proof that the virus cannot live in warm climates.

BTW, I looked up the Winter climate in Rio. Since it is in a tropical zone, the temperature drops all the way down to 70F in the Winter.
And there were a lot of 70+ degree days in Georgia, at least in Augusta, in the winter months, as there always are, so ? Regardless, this is all going to be "proven" one way or another come summer in the US. Quite a few experts are saying that it is seasonal, but what are they basing that on? Only time and warmer temperatures will tell.
 

RonJohn

Helluva Engineer
Messages
4,990
And there were a lot of 70+ degree days in Georgia, at least in Augusta, in the winter months, as there always are, so ? Regardless, this is all going to be "proven" one way or another come summer in the US. Quite a few experts are saying that it is seasonal, but what are they basing that on? Only time and warmer temperatures will tell.

Even if it relaxes in the summer time, it won't be "proven" that it thrives in colder climate zones, nor that hot weather "kills" the virus. I think the biggest difference we have is that I am reading the actual conclusions that article makes and comparing it to the data that they use to arrive at those conclusions. The data they have does not support the conclusions they arrived at. I do ignore all of the political points, because it is just spittle. It has nothing to do with whether the virus will be seasonal, nor if the virus can't survive in warm climates.

The experts I have heard say that they expect that the virus will be seasonal. That is based on what other viruses have worked. But every expert that I have heard say that also says that they aren't sure about that.
 
Messages
13,443
Location
Augusta, GA
Even if it relaxes in the summer time, it won't be "proven" that it thrives in colder climate zones, nor that hot weather "kills" the virus. I think the biggest difference we have is that I am reading the actual conclusions that article makes and comparing it to the data that they use to arrive at those conclusions. The data they have does not support the conclusions they arrived at. I do ignore all of the political points, because it is just spittle. It has nothing to do with whether the virus will be seasonal, nor if the virus can't survive in warm climates.

The experts I have heard say that they expect that the virus will be seasonal. That is based on what other viruses have worked. But every expert that I have heard say that also says that they aren't sure about that.
So they are both sure and unsure about it at the same time. By all means PLEASE watch the video I posted above. It addresses the kinds of differences of opinion that we are faced with today, and it's hilarious.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top