ACC's top QB: Thomas or Winston?

AE 87

AE 87

Helluva Engineer
Messages
13,016
People see Winston and see NFL QB: size, footwork, all the throws with power and touch. They don't see that with Thomas.
 

up state jacket

Banned
Messages
1,403
JT could be the league MVP. Just look at how much better the offense is running with him at the helm vs Vad. I know the line play is better this year, but his decision making on the fly is also a major up grade to last year. He's going to be a beast next year. He could be in for a special year in 15.
 
JazzyD95

JazzyD95

Ramblin' Wreck
Messages
727
Location
The ATL
I feel like JTs throwing motion allows him to be more adept at throwing shorter to intermidiate throws with zip on them. I don't like how he throws the long ball personally. Winston has yet to lose a game as a starter, you can't take the 1rst team all ACC away from him.
 
Boomergump

Boomergump

Helluva Engineer
Featured Member
Messages
3,262
JazzyD95 said:
I feel like JTs throwing motion allows him to be more adept at throwing shorter to intermidiate throws with zip on them. I don't like how he throws the long ball personally. Winston has yet to lose a game as a starter, you can't take the 1rst team all ACC away from him.
Click to expand...
The only way JT gets first team ACC status is if we beat UGA and FSU and he has monster games in both. Then it might happen.
 

GTech63

Helluva Engineer
Messages
1,117
Location
Montgomery, TX (77356)
Eastman said:
If the ratings also included character, a "best example of the student athlete", JT would win in a landslide. So thankful he is representing Tech and not Winston.
Click to expand...
The Heisman is supposed to take player "character" into consideration when making the award. Unfortunately that does not seem to be a consideration, or part of the selection equation, in recent years. IMO it should be considered when selecting the finalists..
 
GT Man

GT Man

Ramblin' Wreck
Messages
898
Whiskey_Clear said:
Mina....I like that premise but there is no way JT gets an invite to the Heisman Ceremony. He won't crack the top 5 in voting even if he torches UGA and FSU. Next year though....yeah he should get some consideration next year if that happens.
Click to expand...
When Calvin (f'n) Johnson didn't win the Heisman, the Heisman became a big joke as far as I'm concerned.
 
heeled soul

heeled soul

Georgia Tech Fan
Messages
52
JT has been absolutely impressive this season. as you all have experienced in the past, the 2nd string QB is usually the fan favorite for many teams. there is no debate for your team this year, so i know you all love him.

early in the season, many UNC fans wanted to see our second string QB mitch trubisky take over for marquise williams. but when marquise finally got the coach's full trust and a chance to shine, he really has been impressive. our underwhelming season would've been a disaster without his ability to take the team out of huge holes entirely on his shoulders (btw, we're ranked 125th in points allowed). obviously, there is no longer a debate at UNC, and we all love him, again... just as we did when he was second string.

fwiw, marquise is the only QB with three weekly ACC offensive back honors. deshaun watson has two. four others have one each... JT, winston, brissett (NCSU) and murphy (BC). another factoid: marquise also has 3 wins under his belt when his defense has given up 500+ yards.

obviously, i may be alone in this forum but he'd be my choice for 1st team all ACC.
 

kittysniper101

Jolly Good Fellow
Messages
166
heeled soul said:
JT has been absolutely impressive this season. as you all have experienced in the past, the 2nd string QB is usually the fan favorite for many teams. there is no debate for your team this year, so i know you all love him.

early in the season, many UNC fans wanted to see our second string QB mitch trubisky take over for marquise williams. but when marquise finally got the coach's full trust and a chance to shine, he really has been impressive. our underwhelming season would've been a disaster without his ability to take the team out of huge holes entirely on his shoulders (btw, we're ranked 125th in points allowed). obviously, there is no longer a debate at UNC, and we all love him, again... just as we did when he was second string.

fwiw, marquise is the only QB with three weekly ACC offensive back honors. deshaun watson has two. four others have one each... JT, winston, brissett (NCSU) and murphy (BC). another factoid: marquise also has 3 wins under his belt when his defense has given up 500+ yards.

obviously, i may be alone in this forum but he'd be my choice for 1st team all ACC.
Click to expand...

You're absolutely right, but I think what you may see come into play is the typical award bias in that they will consider a player from an overall successful team before they begin looking at players further down the line. There are certainly some good quarterbacks in our conference and it will be interesting to see who wins.
 
Top