2024 non-GT games thread

YoungSting

Jolly Good Fellow
Messages
316
Or the home-field advantage is too strong an advantage. If you flip who's hosting, does that change the outcome? I think it does.
In which of the blowouts do you think it changes the outcome? These teams barely squeaked into the playoffs. I’m not going to pretend to act like they have a chance. These games have shown there’s a gap between the top 5-6 teams and the 10-12 teams
 

jgtengineer

Helluva Engineer
Messages
3,066
In which of the blowouts do you think it changes the outcome? These teams barely squeaked into the playoffs. I’m not going to pretend to act like they have a chance. These games have shown there’s a gap between the top 5-6 teams and the 10-12 teams
The only one i thi k might be different was Texas Clemson. Clemson made to many mistakes but had chances
 

CEB

Helluva Engineer
Messages
2,790
Four teams earned a bye. After that its opinion as the prior BCS and 4 team CFP were.

Seems the CFP Committee got 5-8 correct vs 9-12
Eh… maybe.
Looking like the 8/9 game might be the biggest blow out of all, and I’m thinking home field is a huge benefit. I think these would all be a lot more competitive at neutral sites.
After a sample size of just one, I’m thinking the 5 and 6 seeds are a REALLY good place to be in the current format.
 

CEB

Helluva Engineer
Messages
2,790
In which of the blowouts do you think it changes the outcome? These teams barely squeaked into the playoffs. I’m not going to pretend to act like they have a chance. These games have shown there’s a gap between the top 5-6 teams and the 10-12 teams
Looks like the biggest gap may be between 8 and 9…
 

YoungSting

Jolly Good Fellow
Messages
316
Eh… maybe.
Looking like the 8/9 game might be the biggest blow out of all, and I’m thinking home field is a huge benefit. I think these would all be a lot more competitive at neutral sites.
After a sample size of just one, I’m thinking the 5 and 6 seeds are a REALLY good place to be in the current format.
We knew the 5 seed was the place to be. You probably didn’t play in your conference championship, so you get a bye. Then you play the worst team in the playoffs. You also avoid the number 1 team, and get the worse of the auto bids.
 

Root4GT

Helluva Engineer
Messages
3,351
Eh… maybe.
Looking like the 8/9 game might be the biggest blow out of all, and I’m thinking home field is a huge benefit. I think these would all be a lot more competitive at neutral sites.
After a sample size of just one, I’m thinking the 5 and 6 seeds are a REALLY good place to be in the current format.
Too soon to tell. Being a higher seed should have some advantage. Playing 3 of 4 games in sub freezing temperatures is great. Southern teams never face that challenge. Seems they don’t handle it very well
 

CEB

Helluva Engineer
Messages
2,790
We knew the 5 seed was the place to be. You probably didn’t play in your conference championship, so you get a bye. Then you play the worst team in the playoffs. You also avoid the number 1 team, and get the worse of the auto bids.
Well, both the 5& 6 seed played in their conf champ this year. Obviously no way to know if that pans out the same going forward but its going to be hard to seed a 5 or 6 that didn’t participate in a conf champ game unless it’s Notre Dame.
That said, 5/6 seeds are good place to be.
 

forensicbuzz

21st Century Throwback Dad
Messages
9,048
Location
North Shore, Chicago
The way the games played out only Clemson was competitive and I don’t see them beating Texas anywhere. SMU looked awful vs Penn St. Tenn looks lost at Ohio State. Seems the cold weather is a factor which I think is great.
Don't minimize the home-field advantage. I think it was huge. All 4 hosting teams won handily. There wasn't that big a difference between those teams. I think in Death Valley, Clemson beats Texas.
 

Northeast Stinger

Helluva Engineer
Messages
11,153
Too soon to tell. Being a higher seed should have some advantage. Playing 3 of 4 games in sub freezing temperatures is great. Southern teams never face that challenge. Seems they don’t handle it very well
The cold may be a psychological factor but I’ve heard players say once the game starts you don’t even notice it. On the other hand I’ve heard players not used to playing in hot high humidity weather that it was a major distraction.
 

Northeast Stinger

Helluva Engineer
Messages
11,153
Can't wait to hear Herbstreit talk about how Tennessee was outclassed tonight and didn't belong on that field with Ohio St and how the committee needs to do a better job of avoiding letting teams like them in when they are just going to get blown out.
So the narrative so far is that home field advantage is a factor. Herbstreit, during the game, made a point of saying Ohio State is something like 4-10-2 all time against the SEC. He didn’t like hearing OSU fans chanting, SEC, SEC, SEC, taunting Tennessee fans. The game seemed to hurt their feelings a little bit.
 

stinger78

Helluva Engineer
Messages
4,929
Our commissioner stomped his foot to demand make up pick for the snub a previous acc team with no qb
.
Our time in wilderness continues.
.
The bottom 4 seeds (9, 10, 11, and 12) all lost. We were #’s 11 and 12. There was no surprise in this.

Clemson played the closest game. IN was down 27-3 in the 4th before scoring 2 junk time TD’s. The SECheat’s UTK lost worst of all while playing the lowest seeded opponent of the 4 winners.
 

iceeater1969

Helluva Engineer
Messages
9,776
The bottom 4 seeds (9, 10, 11, and 12) all lost. We were #’s 11 and 12. There was no surprise in this.

Clemson played the closest game. IN was down 27-3 in the 4th before scoring 2 junk time TD’s. The SECheat’s UTK lost worst of all while playing the lowest seeded opponent of the 4 winners.
Next year when we win acc, the acc commissioner can demand that committee forget the last 2 years, we should be a top seed.
No, the acc is the doormat.

Gt will gladly play thier way up.the brackets.

We dont want the commissioner to stomp his foot.
 
Top