SteamWhistle
Helluva Engineer
- Messages
- 4,436
- Location
- Rome, GA
If I see anyone not in white tonight, you will be shunned from the GT Community.
FTFYIf I see anyone not in white tonight, they will be shunned from the GT Community.
Anyone is a singular pronoun. While it is indefinite, it is a singular indefinite pronoun, and "they" contradicts subject agreement. It would be like saying "One of the girls gave up their seat", which is grammatically incorrect, as it should be "One of the girls gave up her seat." "You" is also indefinite, but it could refer to a singular person or a plural group of people; in this case, it is being used as a singular pronoun. Therefore, "you" is correct, as is "he" and "she" if you is replaced with either of those, but "they" is incorrect. Next time you try to correct someone's grammar, make sure you actually know what you're talking aboutFTFY
I know we're mostly engineers here , but it really hurts your argument when you don't use proper grammar.
Anyone is a singular pronoun. While it is indefinite, it is a singular indefinite pronoun, and "they" contradicts subject agreement. It would be like saying "One of the girls gave up their seat", which is grammatically incorrect, as it should be "One of the girls gave up her seat." "You" is also indefinite, but it could refer to a singular person or a plural group of people; in this case, it is being used as a singular pronoun. Therefore, "you" is correct, as is "he" and "she" if you is replaced with either of those, but "they" is incorrect. Next time you try to correct someone's grammar, make sure you actually know what you're talking about
That's fine and well, using the singular they like that (although having taken English classes under several distinguished professors, all of them disregard that use and actively dissuade it, the same way I dislike how the word literally now has a secondary definition meaning figuratively), but the original point was that you can't be used in the sentence, and must be replaced with they, implying that you is singular and should be changed out for the plural they. That is incorrect. If you wish to use the singular they, that's also fine, but you, he, and she all work just as well if not better. This is the last point I'm going to make about this, however, because I don't want this thread to derail into a grammar threadI'm with @Blumpkin Souffle (note item three):
They: pronoun, possessive their or theirs, objective them.
1. nominative plural of he, she, and it.
2. people in general:
They say he's rich.3. (used with a singular indefinite pronoun or singular noun antecedent in place of the definite masculine he or the definite feminine she):
Whoever is of voting age, whether they are interested in politics or not, should vote. A person may apply only if they are over 21. They have been an actor since childhood.
(from www.dictionary.com)
That being said, I'm okay with the wording in the OP--I'm just saying that the use of 'they' in this context is entirely acceptable.
Agreed.[...] because I don't want this thread to derail into a grammar thread
Only got a yellow shirt with white letters.. spent over half my pay check on taking my little bro to the game. Don't get on me to hardIf I see anyone not in white tonight, you will be shunned from the GT Community.
you're just mean.I sure hoping us going win tonight and you’s all will going to where white cuz; it be the white out game–Go Jackets!
You have the best name / handle on the board!!wow I'm glad I read this thread before leaving. I was going to bring my red shirt but went back and got a white one