Gold1
Helluva Engineer
- Messages
- 3,359
Nope. We won'tWe actually very easily could. And might. But I doubt it.
Nope. We won'tWe actually very easily could. And might. But I doubt it.
Man i really want GC to be the coach. He would give Kirby smart fits. He would have us in contention with legit 4 and 5 star talent.
Other than saban, urban, and dabo, no one is going to get 5*'s at GT anytime soon.
Remember, GTSwarm, this is my opinion - it is not life and death - I am ok with others having a different opinion than Vamos and me.
Calvin Johnson should have been a five star. Someone in his mold might be our first. A 5 star from Georgia, with a burning desire for a top shelf degree and desire to stay close to home. I wonder how many of those are out there... Hmmm...Gold1, I was going to warn you the "we can't get 5*s at GT" would start coming, but I was too slow.
I'm a few pages behind in my reading, but I'm sure you've gotten a few about money, academics, etc., already.
No, not Peek. The Peek situation was fine with me. The C.Jackson situation is what made the headlines (and that he may have called some of our other recruits while he was still here). In the C.Jackson situation, he went to Chris during a dead period, and got away with it, and got him to go to Bama over GT (which was bad for GT and ended up being even worse for Chris).
I don't want to overstate my own feelings or the situation. I don't know all of the facts. I do remember there being major shade on Geoff Collins when all this went down and everyone saying that Collins had burned all of his bridges at GT. That's not something an inherently ethical person does. That's shady business. I can't imagine any of the ethical men I've ever known to conduct themselves in that way and alienate an entire set of people for his own gain. I know a lot of men who would do things like that, and I don't want them as leaders of any organization I'm a part of.
If Collins is the guy, I'll be disappointed and suspicious. I won't be close minded and think I know everything. I would be open to him proving me wrong.
It was scout back then but yes Calvin Johnson is the only one. He was a high 4 star on rivals.How many 5 stars have we ever had? Hell I think only 247 rated Calvin as a 5 star.
Neither. Todd needs to help and do his job.
No one is arguing that fit should not be considered. The question is how much deference fit should be given over prior, demonstrated success. While prior performance is not indicative of future performance, it often strongly correlates.
And he wasn't a 5star until they did retrospective rankings years later. GT has yet to land a 5star at time of signing in its history.How many 5 stars have we ever had? Hell I think only 247 rated Calvin as a 5 star.
I wasn't going to bring it up, but Stanford signed a 5 star QB from GAC, and they've signed 5 star OL too. Stanford doesn't recruit like UGAg or Clemson, but they sign enough talent to be where I think we could be. If there's going to be an infusion of $$$$ as some have runored, there are opportunities if we recruit nationally combined with a good HC hire .Our best shot at a 5* would be at QB in an offense that had a potential to get them to the NFL. The right QB opens access to top WR's and TE as well. They want to touch the ball every now and then. I never liked the fact that our WR's were not rewarded more with pass attempts for blocking their butts off.
That is a really good quote, and thank you, Gold1, for sharing that.
5 star players go where they think it is the "easiest" path to the NFL - that will never be the Institute, unless the NFL adopts the one and done rule, like the NBA/Men's College hoops.
No he was definitely a 5 star when he signed with Tech according to scout. Believe they had him the #3 WR in the nation that year.And he wasn't a 5star until they did retrospective rankings years later. GT has yet to land a 5star at time of signing in its history.
Maybe, I heard one of the sites went back and retroactively changed his score. I have no way of confirming or refuting this claim. I have found many articles mentioning "5 star recruits in the NFL" and Calvin was not listed. Absense of evidence isn't proof though, but I remember when I was a student people saying "I can't believe he's only a 4 star".No he was definitely a 5 star when he signed with Tech according to scout. Believe they had him the #3 WR in the nation that year.
Hey, don't besmirch the Cheetah's fine name by associating it with Hugh Freeze.