You would have a LOT more kids transferring every single year if you didn't have the rule. I agree with it for the most part. I actually think it's hilarious when these young men think because I'm going to UGA, Bama, USC etc. that they're set for life because that is what they have been told to get them to commit. Football isn't everything but the younger generations only thinks NFL. Football doesn't last forever. I think that is what separates GT from the pack.
I am not libertarian, a free market zealot, or a Tea Party guy ranting about rights. But simply, say a lot of players transfer. So what? I don't presume to know why player X went to SC, or Y went to GT, only what an 18-year-old says at the time. (Master's project: how many graduating football players actually do what they said they went to a particular school to do?) Going from when I was 18 most of them already have a pretty good idea of their ceiling. It is sobering, and a dream is gone, but there it is. Coaches, ADs, college presidents change their minds, and as we saw this year, recruiting coaches lie a kid into signing, then leap to another job paying more money. Every single one of them is on the make for the next big job and will walk in a minute with a bronze statue waiting. Why are they different? From all indications Charles Kelly loved GT, enjoyed working for and even admired Johnson. FSU waved a three-year contract instead of a one, doubled his salary, and he called the moving van. A single guy might, might, have stayed. But a married guy with kids? Who blames him? The fact remains he was gone and the players he helped recruit did not have that choice. If one wants to limit the transfers to one-per, fine. Want to put in a window for the decision so that the present coach knows what to recruit for? Fine. Get it right the second time or lose a year. But to charge a kid 25% of his eligibility because he wilted to pressure? If one wants to stipulate that any college football coach caught tampering with somebody else's players is banned for life, I am on board. Sorry for bloviating, but fans vacillate between treating players like idols, or cattle. Besides which the NCAA is such a mess it can't be worse anyway.