If you read my post you would see that I NEVER claimed that they set up correctly. By arguing that I did you are not arguing against the position I took and are arguing against a “straw man” that you created, hence yours is a straw man argument. My point was not that they made errors but that you oversimplified the situation in order to criticize. These are bright kids who take on hard academics and major college football and take it very seriously. I think you should cut them some slack and give them support.
I'm totally lost with your argument.
My entire point is that they lined up wrong on several plays, you stated "I NEVER claimed that they set up correctly" so it's obvious that you think I'm right, that they lined up wrong, yet you go further and say "My point was not that they made errors but that you oversimplified the situation in order to criticize".
I asked why the mistake was made. I based my lack of understanding of the "mistakes" on the fact that these kids are exceptionally smart, as proven by the classes they take. It seems that you are over sensitive to negative descriptions or questions. I never said they do it on purpose as your objections infer.
I will once again aske how any Tech students (pointing out that they go to Tech - acknowledging they are exceptional), who can take and pass calculus (not required at most other schools) do not understand that 2 DB's cannot cover 3 WR's (simple math upon observation before the snap) ?
The players DID NOT LINE UP CORRECTLY and/or ADJUST TO WHAT THEY SAW, Its a fact !
I doubt that any student is overwhelmed by the disapproving question and I doubt that they will conduct their approach to life any different due to it.
Your thoughts are fine but to infer that I or anyone else whose questions are valid, of not supporting the team is a very unique position you take. I expect a lot of the people THAT I SUPPORT !
It really sounds like you are one who supports participation trophies, I don't !
If it's so nuanced to play football that you cannot look down the line or in front of you and see the situation your opponent gives you then you could have explained those conditions which excuse the failure. Thats my goal, to understand why they mistakes were made
I'm talking about the game of football, the straw man in this back and forth between us is the one you inserted --- it's it called "feelings"