I'm very surprised to see Lou Young's name on so many lists. I'm also a bit surprised to see Jefferson and Perkins on any of the list. Jefferson and Perkins were solid, but neither were impact players IMO.
In my opinion:
QB - Josh Nesbitt
BB - Jon Dwyer
AB - Robert Godhigh
AB - Anthony Allen
WR - Smelter
WR - BeyBey
OL (regardless of position) - Mason, Gardner, Uzzi, Bedford, Cord
DE - Michael Johnson
DT - Vance Walker
DT - Darryl Richard
DE - Derrick Morgan
LB - Attaochu
LB - Julian Burnett
LB - PJ Davis
CB - Mario Butler
S - Morgan Burnett
S - Jemea Thomas
CB - DJ White
Kicker - Blair
Punter - N/A
PR - Tarrant
KR - Golden
Honorable Mention: Justin Thomas (2014 Justin), Orwin Smith (lacked blocking), Stephen Hill (inconsistent hands), Brad Jefferson (solid), Adam Gotsis, Freeman
I probably left a few people off