Bud Carson replaced Dodd and was Dodds DC.Sure their are others but this comes to mind right away.Where's the evidence that even if MBob got rid of CPJ that he would hire Roof??? I have no idea why people think Roof will be CPJ's successor. People keep saying this and some how it's caught with no evidence backing it up. How often does a head coach hire come from inside the program? I can't remember any but then again I haven't been looking either.
Here's what I think is going on:
The team that scores the most points wins. When we lose our defense gives up more points than our offense can score.
Also how many pick-sixes or other easy touchdowns has our offense given up in garbage time?
Well see where SC hired a guy from outside with ties and players were upset they didnt keep Coach O...football is strange when it comes to coaches.
I wouldn't say Roof is currently a failure as a DC. He has been here one year and our defense was a lot better than last year.
At the pro level, you have head coaches who failed at their first (or even second try) and who have succeeded at their next gig.
And the passing D would have been better had we stayed healthy and/or had the depg in the secondary.Georgia Tech current total defensive ranking is 22nd
With a rushing defense ranked 9th but 85th against the pass
How is that not an significant improvement even with crappy passing stats?
I tend to agree. My only question would be about DL rotation. Was there really no way to keep them fresh thru the game? It wasn't as bad as the Groh years but still a question for me.I think Roof got everything he could have out of the defense this year, considering the personell.
Naw TR did a good job with what he inherited.We only had a small handful of impact players and he did well with them.Need more meat up front though since we are not as stout as the teams we play and always use some cover corners.Roof did good job and maybe we get better next year.One thing though he did get the guys to play hard and we have not seen that in a while.A lot better is a bit of a stretch, but we are improved on D. I wouldn't call him a failure, either.