So there are only two people on the OP’s list with any P5 HC experience, and posters are barfing up on both of them (not everyone).
The other coaches on the list (getting 80% of votes, although not sure about the 13% “other”) have been successful at a lower level, kind of similar to our previous experiment that everyone viewed as such an important bold move, right up until it blew up in our face. Of course we arguably sort of ran off a successful “real coach” to conduct that impressive experiment.
Everyone here probably knows the definition of insanity. Anyway, we’re just kicking around ideas on here with no actual influence, but the thought process is interesting.