Pressley Harvin Quote From ESPN

  • Thread starter Deleted member 2897
  • Start date

Deleted member 2897

Guest
g0lftime said:
Hope he works on his passing skills if we try fake punts this year. Wasn't too swift last year.
Click to expand...

Well it’s hard to hit someone when the defense holds the receiver. I still don’t understand the refs statement on that play that there cannot be a pass interference on a fake punt..
 
deeeznutz

deeeznutz

Helluva Engineer
Messages
2,329
bwelbo said:
Well it’s hard to hit someone when the defense holds the receiver. I still don’t understand the refs statement on that play that there cannot be a pass interference on a fake punt..
Click to expand...

Yup, whether he meant it or not, that ref gave free rein for the outside coverage guys to just maul a blocker/potential receiver coming off the line on a punt. It’s one of the more nonsensical reasons I’ve heard for a call not being made. Did the league ever issue a statement on whether he was correct in his interpretation? Seems like that is something that needs a whole lot more clarity.
 

kittysniper101

Jolly Good Fellow
Messages
174
deeeznutz said:
Yup, whether he meant it or not, that ref gave free rein for the outside coverage guys to just maul a blocker/potential receiver coming off the line on a punt. It’s one of the more nonsensical reasons I’ve heard for a call not being made. Did the league ever issue a statement on whether he was correct in his interpretation? Seems like that is something that needs a whole lot more clarity.
Click to expand...

It's absolutely the correct call. I remember watching an NFL game with a friend the week before and his team getting screwed by the rule and thought to myself, "huh, I wonder how that will haunt GT."

Here's an explanation. https://bleacherreport.com/articles/2111506-6-most-obscure-college-football-rules#slide5
I've heard the justification it is to allow blocking of the gunners. Since they would normally be eligible receivers, you couldn't impede their downfield motion the way you commonly do during a punt play.
 

Deleted member 2897

Guest
kittysniper101 said:
It's absolutely the correct call. I remember watching an NFL game with a friend the week before and his team getting screwed by the rule and thought to myself, "huh, I wonder how that will haunt GT."

Here's an explanation. https://bleacherreport.com/articles/2111506-6-most-obscure-college-football-rules#slide5
I've heard the justification it is to allow blocking of the gunners. Since they would normally be eligible receivers, you couldn't impede their downfield motion the way you commonly do during a punt play.
Click to expand...

My beef was that he wasn’t blocking him as if he were a gunner, he was holding him, which I thought was illegal either way.
 

MWBATL

Helluva Engineer
Messages
6,589
bwelbo said:
My beef was that he wasn’t blocking him as if he were a gunner, he was holding him, which I thought was illegal either way.
Click to expand...
Haven't the rules on holding been relaxed as well? Something like you can do it as long as your arms stay within your shoulders....in other words, you can't reach out and grab a guy but if he is in your grill you can now legally hold him. Or am I mistaken?
 
iceeater1969

iceeater1969

Helluva Engineer
Messages
9,779
after kick off the bend and break made kicking off a waste of time. First we didn't get a chance to recover the onside kick. With the bend but don't break of the recent past the other team is given easy dump passes till they are near field goal range.
 

gtg970g

Jolly Good Fellow
Messages
327
kittysniper101 said:
It's absolutely the correct call. I remember watching an NFL game with a friend the week before and his team getting screwed by the rule and thought to myself, "huh, I wonder how that will haunt GT."

Here's an explanation. https://bleacherreport.com/articles/2111506-6-most-obscure-college-football-rules#slide5
I've heard the justification it is to allow blocking of the gunners. Since they would normally be eligible receivers, you couldn't impede their downfield motion the way you commonly do during a punt play.
Click to expand...
So it's not pass interference but it's still defensive holding correct?
 
Top