I said initially we would have to agree to disagree. You are convinced that transfers were a gold mine for us, I am not. I could nit-pick with you all day about specific players and I doubt either of us would convince the other. I have been hugely disappointed in the impact of our transfers. After several on here touting our offensive line before the season, and CGC saying it would be improved, it and the whole team seemed to regress. If we had gotten so much improvement through transfers we would not have lost to NIU and we would not have gone 3-9. Big flop on all of this.
Not once have I said the transfers are a “gold mine.”
I just said we’ve be helped more with the guys coming in than we have been hurt by guys leaving (save Gibbs).
If you can’t see that, you’re not looking or have an axe to grind.
I will agree with you that I’ve been disappointed with the (lack of) production from some guys. I had high expectations for White this year and Clayton when he came in. Neither have done much.
I’ve also expected more from a few of the DBs we’ve brought in, but they’ve underwhelmed as well.
Still we have several guys getting meaningful minutes and providing depth in positions of need. The only player (other than Gibbs) that we though might hurt was Brown and he was a complete non factor as USCe and would’ve most likely lost his job to McGowen this year if he stayed anyways.