Yes, it is strange to have a seemingly deteriorating kicking room. It is unlike anything I have ever seen and likely that Collins has seen and certainly overseen.
There is data from Temple that suggests Collins is not the issue. How do you interpret the kicking performance at Temple vs now?
I do think it’s possible that a bunch of walk-on kickers are not up to D1 expectations and there could be a mental issue in that room that is sort of a self-fulfilling prophecy. That is not to say I discount the idea that there are coaching elements at play.
I don’t think it’s Collins, I think it’s smaller than that. I think somewhere in this group, which includes the line and holder, some very small detail or lack thereof isn’t getting noticed and fixed. I do think the ATL puts added and unneeded pressure on this position though. Yes ultimately Collins is the head coach but he did say about 2 weeks ago was the first time groups had unit meetings as in QBs, WRs and OL in the same meeting. I’ll bet you that’s the case with the PK units. I don’t know but 4-5 kickers just don't forget how to kick, even 2 star kickers dont miss this bad this consistently and lines don’t get beat off the snap this consistently. There is some mechanical something going on, some technical thing that is or isn’t being done.
as far as Temple, Id have to know more details regarding both staffs and who or how the units are handled, while the how is most likely the same, I’ll bet somebody “new” is working with the PK unit day to day.
im not trying to be mean, this issue is a head scratcher.