MWBATL
Helluva Engineer
- Messages
- 6,595
Just as an FYI, many years ago when I interviewed with HUD in Washington DC, I was informed that if I was the type of person who insisted on hiring the best person for the job that I would not fit in at HUD. Their objectives were social equity and NOT based on merit. That is what federal bureaucracy means to many.Not sure who you were asking the question of but this is what I would say. “Bureaucracy” has, rightly or wrongly, become a stigmatized word. Replace that with the word “organization” and you have a value neutral word that can then be modified with an adjective like good or bad.
I have certainly run into government agencies that were badly run organizations. It may have been bad from the top down or it may be that I simply encounter an incompetent or poor local representative. My good experiences with the government involved the IRS, a U.S. embassy, the Post Office, Georgia State Patrol and Social Security, to name a few. The worst experiences I have ever had with organizations were with restaurants, airlines, retail stores, insurance companies, builders and chambers of commerce.
But my personal experience doesn’t prove any more than your personal experience. Which is why I was looking for something more that I could sink my teeth into.
There is no certainty that private businesses are more effective or efficient, but basing hiring and promotions on merit instead of social equity generally works better.