Well, except that he is using Pitts as our #4 starter right now. I do get that he might be deliberately doing that to see how he pitches and responds, and I do agree he has gotten progressively better. (Still drive me nuts when he walks a guy to lead off an inning...it is AMAZING how often that guy winds up scoring against Pitts.) Honestly, I am not sure who our #5 starter would be.
I am also curious...with the changes to the post season format, you don't need 5 starters in the Super Regionals, and with all the days off now in the CWS I don't think you need more than 4 there either....why do you say we need 5 starters? Only place I can ever see needing it is a Regional that goes the distance....
Well I said "ideally you'd like to have" not need which is a big difference. You definitely don't need 5 but if I'm a coach I'm going to be greedy about it and try to have five potential options if my roster allows it. It's a perfect world kind of thing not a hard rule or anything.
And yes it's mostly for the first round if you end up in the loser's bracket. You can throw a guy on short rest but that's a huge risk with the guys at this level. But it's also good just in case something unforeseen happens injury wise at any point. I like having that extra guy who's at least semi-stretched out. Look at what happened in the 2011 regional where (I think) Pope got hurt right before the first game. It pushed everyone up and we were forced to start Smelter, who hadn't even gone two innings in outing before that IIRC, in the final. If you lose a guy late in the season and you have someone else that can step in with minimal fuss.
Who's that guy for us? Not sure. It's really too early to tell. You obviously have Gold and Hughes looking good so far. Considering King has already missed an entire year with shoulder issues his current soreness there terrifies me so I'm not counting on him until he shows he's past it. Then you have Gibson who's looked ok so far but hasn't lit the world on fire. Gotta see more of him for sure. And we're obviously still figuring out Pitts. On Tuesday the announcers said something about letting Zac Ryan start so if they're right he could be that guy.
Assuming everyone's healthy my guess to the depth chart would be: 1) Gold 2) King 3) Hughes (shocker) and then whoever is performing the best of Pitts, Gibson, and Ryan to be the 4th and 5th guys. It could even be one of the other guys. I mean I don't think anyone had Gold as our best starter this time last year. The good news is the coaching staff has like 3+ months to figure this out and they've got options for the first time in a while.