Not the person you asked, but I think it's instructive to look at some past years. Here are some resumes from the past few years in the ACC. Which ones do you think get in?
Team 1: 32-23 (13-17), 6-13 vs top 50, RPI 38
Team 2: 34-24 (13-16), 9-15 vs top 50, RPI 28
Team 3: 36-23 (13-16), 15-22...