This is where people are seeing the pessimism. (Well, that and that your definition of "succesful" caps out at 8 wins, period, aka "less than the last 3 non-joke coaches peaked at and the last coach beat several times").
We're very early in the NIL era and we have a pretty new administration, let's wait to see how it plays out if Key is that successful. Money and willpower have ways of showing up sometimes when the results are there. And Key, unlike GOL, has much stronger ties to Tech that make the purely-name-based-appeal of other places lower if GT finds the money.
(A discussion about academic requirements about players would be a different one... if Key can't win more than 10 consistently because of that, will he eventually want to try his hand at that game? Quite possibly. But if he only wins 8, he might have a tough time landing one of those jobs anyway. Chan wasn't exactly a hot commodity.)
It’s not my pessimism. This is what GT has shown itself to be. A mid level cheap school not willing to break open the books to give coaches what they need. We can all “hope” GT opens up the purse but the proof is in the actions. Has GT given Key the money to go buy a 5 star LB or DLinemen yet? UGA has, Bama has, etc.
Look at the 2025 recruiting rankings- GT has bought zero 5 stars, 2 4 stars, and 16 3 stars. That’s basically what Gailey, Johnson, and what the other guy recruited. Meanwhile, UGA has already bought 3 5 stars and 12 4 stars for 2025. What part of that indicates we are closing the gap or giving Key more? Dabo who supposedly is on the down fall has already bought 11 4 stars for 2025. How do you think the games in 2026, 2027, and 2028 will go when we are fielding 3 stars while Clemson and UGA are fielding 4 and 5 stars? We’ve won 3 games in 24 years against UGA with that formula.
Listen, I believe Key is a national championship quality coach. What he has done since the other guy was fired has been incredible. I believe you could take our current staff, put them in Tuscaloosa or Athens and they would be in the SEC Champ game and discussion for the Final Four. Kirby is no better a coach than Key. He simply Is given the money by UGA to buy 5 stars and 4 stars. If you were competitive like Key, wouldn’t you want that?
I’m optimistic we’ll have a good year because I believe in our staff. But that doesn’t mean we’ll be beating teams who buy better players. And if Key is fine winning 7-8 games per year then he’s not nearly as competitive as I thought. I expect him to either force GT to buy similarly caliber players or for him to go somewhere where they will.